[MusicXML import] [1.2] import error: 31a-Directions.xml missing dashes and bracket

• Feb 7, 2012 - 16:14
Type
Functional
Severity
3
Status
closed
Project

File 31a-Directions.xml in Reinhold Kainhofers unofficial MusicMXL testsuite imports without dashes and bracket. These could be implemented in MuseScore as lines, with style dash for dashes and lines with hooks on both ends for bracket.


Comments

Severity

I think MuseScore is correct for the bracket by displaying only a line. line-end="none" in the file indicates it's just a line.

Title [MusicXML import] [1.2] import error: 31a-Directions.xml missing dashes and bracket [MusicXML import] [trunk] import error: 31a-Directions.xml missing dashes and bracket
Severity

I would make this one minor, only dashes are concerned as far as I understand. And I would postpone it to 2.0. Speak out if you disagree.

Actually the bracket is currently not imported at all. My point was that the current line can serve as a bracket too, by enabling the line end hooks.

Same goes for the dashes, which are also not imported, while MuseScore does support it as a line with style "dashes".

It is probably a seldom used feature, I wouldn't mind moving it to 2.0.