Sustain Pedal Events are not working properly

Project:MuseScore
Component:Code
Category:bug report
Priority:normal
Assigned:Unassigned
Status:active
Description

It's great that the pedal functionality has been added. Now that I've experimented with it, it needs just a few tweaks.
1) The time to send the 'on' message is just a tick or two after the note starts, and the 'off' message should have one of two possitions--when the note ends, or just before the next note starts. That way, the notes hold for their full duration, a staccato note won't be blurred by pedal where it's not intended. The most important thing this would do, however, is allow one pedal to release and another to begin on the same note. Currently, this situation causes the 2nd pedal marking to have no effect.

2) If a pedal starts on a note with a grace note, it should probably start on the grace note. This is pretty common usage--to sustain the bottom few notes of a chord that is too wide for one hand, while the other notes are struck.

#1
Category:feature request» bug report
#2

I agree.

#3

There is discussion of this problem in this Forum thread:

http://musescore.org/en/node/12642#comment-42743

Perhaps someone woukd take a look at fixing this??

#4
Title:Suggestions for Pedal.» Sustain Pedal Events are not working properly
#5

Point 1 has been adressed in the branch.

#6

Thanks so much for addressing this, I look forward to testing it, I just hope point 2 of my original post won't be forgotten.

Syndicate content