Transpose to F sharp produces G flat
With sharps and naturals, however.
Trying to transpose to another key produces similarly inaccurate results.
Using Mac 10.4.11 and 0.9.6.2.
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
Coincidentally, I am seeing some really weird behavior when trying to transpose from Gb to F#. MuseScore totally ignores transposition requests in both of the following conditions: a) if I request a transposition of a fully selected staff by key (and with key signature change) from Gb to F#; b) if I manually change the key signature and request a transposition of a downward diminished second (sans further key change) for all the notes in the selected part. The only way to get it to work is to change the key signature manually to F#, select all notes that were originally in Gb, use the down arrow to move the notes down by a minor second, and then transpose-operation everything back up by augmented unison. I imagine there's a commonality between chen lung's problems and my own.
In reply to Coincidentally, I am seeing by lossfabulous
lossfabulous, to follow developments on the particular issue you are describing, subscribe to
#4901: Transpose by Key from G major to Cb major inconsistency
Please note that this affects key signatures only, the actual notes should transpose correctly.
Chen lung,
Please provide the steps to reproduce the problem. Without these steps it is difficult to understand what you are referring to.
In reply to Chen lung, Please provide the by David Bolton
OK, open the attached score and transpose it to F Sharp.
Basically, although the notes are F Sharp, the key signature has been simplified to G Flat. (Think this is the problem?)
If you open the transpose box, it shows a key signature of G Flat.
I think it may have been fine on the previous version, so it's a regression?
In reply to OK, open the attached score by chen lung
Previous versions did the same, so it is not a regression. To follow developments on this issue subscribe to
#4901: Transpose by Key from G major to Cb major inconsistency
In reply to Previous versions did the by David Bolton
Ah right.
Could there be a link to this thread to show there's an inconsistency in this key as well?