I believe the editorial accidental in this test should be displayed without parenthesis and it's not the case in the test suite http://kainhofer.com/musicxml/ (Search for 01f-Pitches-ParenthesizedMicrotoneAccidentals.xml).
Opninions vary on this one, our competition also handles this differently:
Finale: no parenthesis on cautionary accidental, editorial accidental printed in parentheses
Sibelius: cautionary accidental not printed, editorial accidental printed in parentheses (this is Lilypond in reverse !)
Furthermore, I consider the parentheses a minor issue. The major issue is that microtone accidentals do not import, even though MuseScore kind-of supports them.
Mmm, we could ask for some clarification on the MusicXML mailing list... I guess the parenthesis is exported separatly then.
Fixed in r5293.
I choose to do cautionary -> parenthesis and editorial -> no parenthesis but at least to display them always. The bug is fixed and should support the import of other accidentals, not included in the test and part of MusicXML 3.0.
Comments
Working on this one
I believe the editorial accidental in this test should be displayed without parenthesis and it's not the case in the test suite http://kainhofer.com/musicxml/ (Search for
01f-Pitches-ParenthesizedMicrotoneAccidentals.xml).Any opinion ?
Opninions vary on this one, our competition also handles this differently:
Finale: no parenthesis on cautionary accidental, editorial accidental printed in parentheses
Sibelius: cautionary accidental not printed, editorial accidental printed in parentheses (this is Lilypond in reverse !)
Furthermore, I consider the parentheses a minor issue. The major issue is that microtone accidentals do not import, even though MuseScore kind-of supports them.
Mmm, we could ask for some clarification on the MusicXML mailing list... I guess the parenthesis is exported separatly then.
Fixed in r5293.
I choose to do cautionary -> parenthesis and editorial -> no parenthesis but at least to display them always. The bug is fixed and should support the import of other accidentals, not included in the test and part of MusicXML 3.0.
also in trunk.
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.