Type In Dynamics Don't Playback

• Aug 27, 2020 - 22:07
Reported version
3.5
Type
Performance
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
by design
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project

Dynamics that are entered via typing in don't play back

(on mac)
1) Cmd-E to type expression text
2) Cmn-Shift-p to type a piano marking
3) Playback, not playing back piano

However, when adding a piano marking as a dynamic it does playback properly.

I understand that according to the program a typed-in dynamic is technically Staff Text, not a Dynamic marking. I can see that when I select it and look at the bottom left of the screen. But it does seem like the program is attempting to give us 2 different ways to achieve the same result, and this playback difference seems like a bug.

I've also noticed that when using "Select Similar" this can be an issue, as a "p" entered as Staff Text, though identical, is not considered the same as a "p" entered as a Dynamic.


Comments

Status active by design

It's not a bug. Staff text, expression text, and dynamics are three different types, only dynamics affect dynamics. But you are free to edit dynamics and type whatever text you want, and use the Inspector to set whatever playback effect you want,

Title Type In Dynamics Don't Playback Yes, but I would REALLY like keyboard shortcuts for dynamics... They're basically the only thing I need to use the mouse for.
Title Yes, but I would REALLY like keyboard shortcuts for dynamics... They're basically the only thing I need to use the mouse for. Type In Dynamics Don't Playback

If you have something to say, do so in the body, nit the title