OMR Scanning PDF to MIDI or MusicXML?
I have to prepare some rehearsal tracks for SATB choir.
There was a good discussion about five years ago on this:
https://musescore.org/en/node/272829
Has there been any update? There seems to have been recent improvements with ML applied to OMR.
I tried MuseScore with the PDF of the Kyrie from the Standford Mass in G.
https://imslp.org/wiki/Mass_in_G_major,Op.46(Stanford,_Charles_Villiers)
It gave a few blank pages then some scattered notes. Not usable at all.
Others I have seen mentioned are:
Neuratron photoscore
PlayScore 2
Audiveris (OSS)
Musitek smartscore-pro
Scan-score
Capella-scan
I don't mind paying as long as I get a free trial so I can run the Stanford on it, and it does enough pages so I know one isn't a fluke.
Comments
This pdf import system in musescore.com is Audiveris.
In reply to This pdf import system in… by hamsandwichnow
But it isn't the complete Audiveris. The complete program is pretty good, but the UI can be a....challenge. I have PhotoScore Lite. It's pretty good. But the light version only does 12 staves.
In reply to But it isn't the complete… by bobjp
Thank you. I found that ScanScore was better but in fact the original PDF was too weak to be good. I might do some more comparative testing when I have time.
In reply to Thank you. I found that… by obeirnepr
You can process the PDF to make it better. Can we have a page of the PDF?
In reply to You can process the PDF to… by bobjp
It's the IMSLP file, in my question.
https://imslp.org/wiki/Mass_in_G_major
In reply to It's the IMSLP file, in my… by obeirnepr
No text. Maybe the copyright status is different here?…
In reply to No text. Maybe the copyright… by hamsandwichnow
Are we looking at the same thing? Here's a picture of the first page of the PDF, the Kyrie with text.
In reply to Are we looking at the same… by probeirne
Sorry, I see the "no text" message in the page now. It's the Novello 1893 score. Maybe my link was wrong, I'll check, How do I delete my previous reply?
In reply to Sorry, I see the "no text"… by probeirne
I see it now, my link was incomplete, broken at the comma
https://imslp.org/wiki/Mass_in_G_major,Op.46(Stanford,_Charles_Villiers)
Sorry!
In reply to I see it now, my link was… by probeirne
Still broken. Let's try the %2C encoding:
https://imslp.org/wiki/Mass_in_G_major%2C_Op.46_(Stanford,_Charles_Vill…
In reply to Still broken. Let's try the … by probeirne
This is a terrible scan of a, no doubt, worse original. I made a PDF of your image and ran it through PhotoScore. I had to do major changes to almost every measure. I left some notes out for speed sake, and produced the result attached.
I'm not sure any software can save this. If I get a chance, I'll try to run it through Audiveris.
In reply to This is a terrible scan of a… by bobjp
That's much better than I got. Here is the first page of the Kyrie using MS Print to PDF.
In reply to That's much better than I… by obeirnepr
Unfortunately, I don't think this is going to work. You could have entered this by hand by now. It really needs to be almost perfect to work right. The only reason the one PhotoScore produced was because it is possible to correct things before committing to xml. It took quite a bit of time to do that. Not really worth it.
In reply to Unfortunately, I don't think… by bobjp
For future readers: I just discovered this detailed review of four scanning apps, with test files attached.
https://www.scoringnotes.com/reviews/a-review-of-optical-music-recognit…
A review of optical music recognition software
January 12, 2021 | by John Hinchey
No clear winner, it depends on your need and budget.