score recognition
Is it too difficult to have a score recognition feature? There are programmes out there like Audiveris and openOMR, which are promissing but not very stable. Could you maybe team up with them and produce a complete package. I would even buy that! You can get windoze stuff that does it but they are a rip off
Rob
Comments
Score recognition software has strangely enough not much relationship with score writer software. The bridge between those two different software packages lays in the MusicXML format: OMR software exports it and MuseScore can import it. That's all there has to be said about it. MuseScore is all about making beautiful scores in an easy way and there it stops.
I struggled with Audiveris and MuseScore for the past 4 hours, but I finally figured out how to make it work without crashing.
By "it" I mean the complete package of scanning a physical score into a JPG, converting it into a digitized score, exporting it to MuseScore, editing and transposing it, and then printing it.
The problem I had was basically that while Audiveris works to import scanned score pictures and clean them up, its MusicXML export feature exports XML files that cause MuseScore to crash, which basically renders it all useless to me because I needed to be able to use MuseScore's additional features (not available in Audiveris) including transposition before I could finally print.
The key was to realize that Audiveris can also export the digitized scores into MIDI format, and it does so accurately (unlike its MusicXML process). Once you have the MIDI, you can import that into MuseScore, and then fill in the minor details that are missing. Yes, it does miss some of the stuff that you would have gotten via MusicXML. But MuseScore kept crashing over and over again no matter how I shortened, editing and otherwise tried to get Audiveris's exported MusicXML into MuseScore.
Using MIDI as the transition format is the best way I've found, and once I figured it out, the details were easy and fast to fix in MuseScore.
Good luck!
In reply to Audiveris works with MuseScore by asleep
Would you share some MusicXML file generated by Audiveris? It would be very valuable information to fix the crashes in MuseScore.
In reply to Audiveris works with MuseScore by asleep
There is a new beta version of Audiveris (v4.0) which was released in December 2010.
http://kenai.com/projects/audiveris/downloads