Breath mark position in playback (V1.3 to 2.0)

• Nov 10, 2013 - 18:46

Hi there,
maybe I found a bug, trying to import a V1.3 file to V2.0?

My system is Win7 64bit, Musescore 1.3 and 2.0 (3fb02f7)

Using a breath mark sign in V1.3 did not influence playback in V1.3 (try playback of attached file MusescoreProblemV1.3orig+bm.mscz).
Importing a file created in V1.3 into V2.0, playback adds a short break before the note the breath mark sign stands after (open & listen in V2.0 playback of MusescoreProblemV1.3orig+bm.mscz).
Removing the breath mark sign in V1.3 before the import to V2.0 removes the break in playback also (open & listen in V2.0 playback of MusescoreProblemV1.3orig-bm.mscz).
Removing the breath mark sign after import in V2.0 keeps the break at playback.

Imported breath mark signs from V1.3 to V2.0 are correctly positioned for printout.
Imported breath marks from V1.3 to V2.0 are incorrectly positioned for playback: before and not after the marked note for the breath mark insert in V1.3
Imported breath mark signs in V2.0 can only be removed for printout, but not so for playback
Exporting that file (breathmark removed in V2.0) from V2.0 to XML and re-importing it to V2.0 corrects the problem.

Anyway - Musescore is a great piece of software!
Best regards

Ps.: Am I posting to the right forum here? Better move to the issue tracker?


In reply to by Shoichi

Thanks for reminding me to re-open the file: this solves the problem that playback still keeps the breath mark even when it is deleted from the score.

Anyway, the main problem is kept even in the actual nightly 36a4aad: breath marks saved in V1.3 are shown on screen and printout behind the "accented" note, importing the file to V2.0 shows the sign at the correct position (screen, printout) but plays it before the note.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.