Changing Volume on a Single, Sustained Note- a Thought

• Jul 9, 2015 - 04:33

I was thinking how it might be possible to change the volume on a single, sustained note (crescendo on, say, a held clarinet note over several measures) since it currently cannot be trivially done due to how MIDIs take note input. Each part of a note contains two portions- the initialization of the note, and the sustain of the note. The initialization is the part that plays over and over- the thing you'll mostly hear whenever you do a tremolo. This portion is fixed-length. The sustain portion is the actual note proper when held, and is what actually changes length depending on the note. This is all handled in the soundfont. I was thinking... is there a way to program a special "sustain" version of a note that is just the sustained part of the note, without the initialization portion? If so, it would be possible to simply break down a note that's supposed to change volume while held into a bunch of smaller notes of just the sustained portion, and have each one change volume progressively. This would also work for things like trills and tremolos on woodwinds or brass (currently it sounds like each note requires a new breath, hence why the bass flute cannot actually be heard when doing a trill); having each note be the sustained portion would make it sound much more fluid and correct. I'm not sure if this is possible, but it is just a thought on how it could be done. This obviously makes sense for more instruments than others (it would be silly on a piano or drum).


Comments

Sadly the soundfont specification doesn't work in this manner.

In order to support this kind of (de)crescendo we need MuseScore to support MIDI controller #11 (Expression).

I'm hoping that it may be possible after igevorse's work this summer.

In reply to by ChurchOrganist

Well, I cannot wait if that's the case. I'm sitting on so many songs that I want to put into the system, but cannot because they just do not sound good without the right volume control.

And then there's Noches en los Jardines de España which can never be done because for some reason digital pianos cannot play the piano parts well at all. Now, if that were ever possible, I'd have to dedicate an entire week just to sticking it onto Musescore.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.