Musicxml export - text lines and hairpins not exported, summing up

• Feb 2, 2019 - 13:15
Reported version
3.0
Type
Functional
Frequency
Many
Severity
S2 - Critical
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project

Hello again,
Today I am really frustrated by this set of issues. When I check my braille transcription of this score:
https://musescore.com/user/30859765/scores/5387618
I found there are two problems:
1. All "hairpin"s set using textline are not exported in Musicxml, and this was mentioned earlier. This even causes all texts like cresc., dim., poco a poco cresc. not being able to exported into musicxml. What's more, in this piece:
https://musescore.com/user/30859765/scores/5412208
all text lines marked "cresc." are exported as a diminuendo line, and this is quite misleading.
2. Back to the Chopin score, from measure 242 on, all hairpins are not exported, and I have to look into the code to find all of them. Perhaps this is because of there are other text lines, but I don't know.
I believe these two issues are related, because they are all about the spanners. I'm really frustrated, and I quite suspect whether my braille transcription will beat the quality of my Open Braille Music Project down, and harm blind musicians a lot. These are very basic problems, and none of other notation softwares have such kind of problems. I even suspect whether I can continue the Open Score Braille project, unless we just do easier works. From Musescore 3.0 to 3.0.2, I see nothing improved with Musicxml, and I think if I have to return to Finale or Sibelius. But that engraving costs too much, so this becomes a dead loop. Sorry for my complaints, but today I'm really shocked by such strange problems, and have spent about 4 hours on such things which could have been avoided! Hope these can be solved soon. I don't hope all symbols can be exported into Musicxml, but having so basic problems already causing harm to the transcription. Sorry again, and I'm looking forward to the improvements.

Regards
Haipeng


Comments