instance of misplaced notes vs ledger line using cross-staff beaming
MuseScore 2.02, windows 10 PC
Please see measure 14 of the attached.
In the right-hand piano part, if the cross-staffed beam in the first half of the measure is moved up to above the notes (so as to be like the measures before & after it), the b4/c4 notes shift to the right, however the ledger lines do not move to match.
I'm only trying to do this to stay faithful to the source document; I'm not aware of any other need to make the change in where the beams lay. Still, MuseScore should be able to do this without any issues.
The problem seems to occur whenever two notes have to "share" the same ledger line when cross-staff beaming is used, and the beams are moved to above the notes. It is easily reproduced in any similar measures in the attached piece.
Thanks,
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| 10 Hor ich das Liedchen klingen.mscz | 30.76 KB |
Comments
and for the record: Looks the same in current master. I don't see what is wrong with it though?
In reply to and for the record: Looks the by Jojo-Schmitz
The picture in your reply is with the beams in the default position, between the staves, is good. But if you select the beam and drag it to above the notes (as in the previous measure), then the issue presents.
In reply to and for the record: Looks the by Jojo-Schmitz
I remember this bug. It's fixed in current master in fact (Jojo, read again the part where you need to move the beam above the notes).
In reply to I remember this bug. It's by [DELETED] 5
Good news then. Does being fixed "in current master" mean that the next MuseScore release will have it resolved?
Thanks,
In reply to Good news then. Does being by marty strasinger
Only if it also is in the 2.0.3 branch
Edit: I've just tried, seems fixed in 2.0.3 too