Articulations in imported XML files not always honored

• Jan 8, 2018 - 08:25

I've imported an XML file (original source: Sibelius) containing a flute part. It includes some staccatos, but they don't actually play. I've copied some sample to a new score. When played, it sounded as a piano instead of flute, so I had to change instrument. Surprisingly, then the staccatos played correctly.
In order to find out why, I saved both scores as MSCX and examined them with a text viewer. I've found that the original one lacked some basic information. All that was there is


<Instrument>
<longName>Flauta</longName>
<trackName>Flute (2)</trackName>
<Channel>
<program value="73"/>
<controller ctrl="10" value="63"/>
<synti>Fluid</synti>
</Channe>
</Instrument>

Basically, the MIDI ID of the Instrument and little more.

On the contrary, the other file, for which I had manually chosen the instrument, contained much more information, such as instrument range and, most importantly,


<Articulation name="staccato">
<velocity>100</velocity>
<gateTime>50</gateTime>
</Articulation>

This gave me the clue for the solution: To select manually the instrument.

However, I wonder why, in the absence of instrument information within the score file, it is not taken from the Instruments.xml file included with Musescore.


Comments

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.