MusicXML X positions of dynamics incorrect on export.

• Nov 21, 2018 - 21:33

MusicXML specfies that the default-x for directives, such as dynamics, "changes the origin relative to the start of the current measure". However MuseScore (2.3.2) incorrectly uses the following note-head. Is this likely to be fixed or will this be a permanent MuseScore "feature"?

The MusicXML specification says:
"For the following elements, the default-x value changes the origin relative to the start of the current measure:
- note
- figured-bass
- harmony
- link
- directive
- measure-numbering
- all descendants of the part-list element
- all children of the direction-type element
"

James


Comments

JoJo's reference is about MuseScore's handling of positioning on import (and is valid). I am talking about EXPORT. MuseScore is not following the standard for the default-x for directives, such as dynamics. They should be relative to the previous bar, not the note.

If it is not to be fixed, could you at least document which ones obey the standard and which do not?

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.