Spurious CC2 events in MIDI out
Reported version
3.6
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S4 - Minor
Reproducibility
Always
Status
active
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
When playing a score via MIDI out, MuseScore sends many CC2 (Breath MSB) messages between the Note-On/Offs. Typically, all the messages send the same value (60), so there's no need for this even if the event were necessary - but it is not, in most cases.
For an example, see the attached "Yesterday" score: Play it via MIDI out into some MIDI-recording software, then those CC2 will turn up. I have added a zip file of logs for the various MIDI channels that show these events, recorded with ReaControlMIDI in Reaper.
Edit: It seems these CC2s also occur in MIDI exports. See attached "Drehorgeltest" files.
H.M.
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
20220410x-ch+p.Yesterday.logs_.zip | 13.3 KB |
20220410x-ch+p.Yesterday.mscz | 22.13 KB |
Drehorgeltest.mscz | 11.49 KB |
Drehorgeltest.csv | 9.47 KB |
Drehorgeltest.mid | 1.19 KB |