There should be Treble and Bass Dynamics

• Dec 4, 2024 - 22:19

When I am writing music, I need the Bass dynamic to be pp and the Treble dynamic mp. I can't do that with Musescore. I click the Bass note and insert pp directly on the Bass staff, yet instead of just changing the Bass staff, it changes both the Bass and the Treble to pp. That is not musically accurate! If you have over 13M users plus professionals, you have to have every detail accurate. You also say you are a Professional music writing software. Well someone who writes advanced and complex music needs those small details.

A quick rough sketch below:

Attachment Size
canvas.png 111.71 KB

Comments

In reply to by bobjp

I would really like to see you draw with a mouse that won't work properly when you're in a rush. This Forum is to help people not to (Non constructive) criticize them. Some people might consider your comment offensive. Luckily it was directed at someone who does not get offended easily. Now please, either help out or let an expert answer my request.

In reply to by hybrid84

Sorry you took my comment the wrong way. It was, possibly, out of place. What you wanted was clear from the title of your thread. So a drawing was not needed. Nor were the comments about MuseScore. I agree that there are things that need attention. The software is not perfect. There are much faster ways to get an image. You could take a screenshot of the area of a score in question and post that. I can't even draw stick people by hand. Not to mention with a mouse. Which is the only reason I said anything.

In reply to by bobjp

Thank you, it's no problem. I couldn't take a screenshot because I use a Chromebook and only borrow a Windows for composition. It was occupied at that time. I'm not an expert on Musescore so I did not know there was an option in the Properties panel.

Thank you though.

You are asking for help in this forum.
You wrote:
If you have over 13M users plus professionals, you have to have every detail accurate. You also say you are a Professional music writing software. Well someone who writes advanced and complex music needs those small details.

How do those critical statements of yours add any relevance to the problem you thought existed, but actually doesn't?

BTW: Did you ever get your volta lines to work?
https://musescore.org/en/node/369814

In reply to by Jm6stringer

They add quite a bit of relevance. I am a composer known in Canada, USA, and Italy, and need my scores' audio to be as accurate as possible. My compositions are being performed by a great Italian pianist who has played at Carnegie Hall in New York and to the President of Italy and several more places around the world, he is very virtuoso in piano. What I'm saying is for people who need to compose quality content to get better likes and views, the platform they use must be at least 97% flawless.

And no, I was never able to get my Volta lines to work. Instead, I came up with a solution to hold down shift and select measures. I still look forward for Musescore to make the Volta lines dragable like pedal lines as it is more efficient.

In reply to by hybrid84

You wrote:
They add quite a bit of relevance.

What?? ...quite a bit of relevance??
You thought your problem (as expressed in the title) was:
There should be Treble and Bass Dynamics
... and so, you opened a new feature request

Then you stated:
When I am writing music I need the Bass dynamic to be pp and the Treble dynamic mp. I can't do that with Musescore.
My point about relevance is that, for example, the word "clef" might be relevant, so you could have written: "Bass clef dynamic to be pp and the Treble clef dynamic mp".
Also, mentioning "grand staff" (e.g., for piano) would have been even more helpful and relevant

All this other stuff you wrote:
If you have over 13M users plus professionals, you have to have every detail accurate. You also say you are a Professional music writing software. Well someone who writes advanced and complex music needs those small details.
...is completely useless and irrelevant, especially in light of the fact that what you have requested is a feature that already exists -- of which you were ignorant. It's okay, though, as that is why this forum and its volunteers are here -- to enlighten you.

P.S.: If you still struggle with voltas, you are welcome to continue any relevant conversations in that thread.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.