Cannot hear second voice when in playback mode
When trying to playback a part of Leo Brouwers ‘Etude No.6’ (see attachment, sorry no .mscz file), I
cannot hear the second voice. The down stem A (second voice) should be sustained
until the last sixteenth down stem note A. What am I doing wrong?
Joe.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| No-Second-Voice.jpg | 120.95 KB |
Comments
Can't tell without the file you're working on.
Please post it as an attachment :)
In reply to Need the mscz file to tell by ChurchOrganist
O.K. Here it is.....
Joe.
In reply to O.K. Here it is..... Joe. by JoeAlders
The two notes are played on the same MIDI channel and note off event is send at the end of the short one. That's why you can't hear the long one. I guess it can be considered as a bug.
In reply to The two notes are played on by [DELETED] 5
If you move the sixteenth notes that overlap the long ones up (or down) so they are not on the same note, they both play with the proper durations.
In reply to If you move the sixteenth by schepers
All right, but that does not solve my problem.....
Joe.
In reply to All right, but that does not by JoeAlders
I know, its an effect I've not seen before.
OK, I just found an answer and where the bug is. Swap voice 1 and 2 and your guitar piece plays OK. If a note in voice 1 overlaps a note in voice 2, the voice 2 note will cut off with voice 1 and no longer hold.
In reply to O.K. Here it is..... Joe. by JoeAlders
It seems you have run into one of the inadequacies of playback in MuseScore.
Hopefully this will be addressed in a later version as it is going to affect anyone writing in closed score format sooner or later.
Good to know about swapping voices 1 & 2 btw :)
Maybe someone should file an issue?
In reply to MuseScore wont play this back properly by ChurchOrganist
I did. #12971: Same note in different voices and lengths plays only the length of the shortest note