Entering notes via computer or MIDI keyboard to transposing instrument
When entering notes via computer or MIDI keyboard onto the stave of a transposing instrument, should it be the actual pitch, or where it would be on a non-transposing instrument?
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
At least in the case of the computer entry, it should and does depend on the setting of "Concert Pitch" - that is indeed the whole point of the button. Concert Pitch on, note entry and display is at sounding pitch. Concert Pitch off, note entry and display is at written pitch. MIDI playback of course should always be sounding pitch. I'd be inclined to say that means input should also always be sounding pitch, but I don't think that's right. You should be able to take an already-printed alto saxophone part and play it in via MIDI at written pitch with "Concert Pitch" turned off, and have it work. Meaning MIDI input should honor Concert Pitch just like all other input.
Having problems writing for Alto Flute - a G transposing instrument. I suspect its a midi issue - as there doesn't seem to be any midi instrument that is for G transposing. If I write the part in concert pitch, then transpose up a fourth, the printed part is correct - but there's no way to play it correctly, either with "concert pitch" button off or on. Any solution I'm missing? TIA!
In reply to Having problems writing for by Ron B - Flute C
Control / click on the instrument name in the score to get to staff properties. There you will find the item "play transposition". It allows you to enter the Transposing interval. That should fix it.
BTW concert pitch does not influence play back, as far as I know. If it is off you enter the notes of transposing instruments as written. If it is on you enter them as they sound. If you have instruments that are on the list things are easy. For a "new" transposing instrument you need to set it up in staff properties.
In reply to Having problems writing for by Ron B - Flute C
Just use the exisitng Alto Flute instrument. It's not in the list of "Common Instruments", but type "flute" into the search box in the isntrument list and you'll see it. Switch to that isntrument and everything should work correctly.
In reply to Just use the exisitng Alto by Marc Sabatella
Right on, thank you so much! As a recent convert from Finale software, I've been most impressed with Musescore - I find it much more intuitive to use, and very well supported with its online help. I haven't had much to do with midi since early 90's, so getting up to speed may take a while :)