Custom Key signatures bug
A custom key signature created via Master palette doesn't work well. They are applied "on line" but not "in key":
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
A custom key signature created via Master palette doesn't work well. They are applied "on line" but not "in key":
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
It's not a bug; you need to define how the key signature should look for each clef individually, since MsueScore cannot know which staff lines you wish to use. Eventually there should be a way to define this, but for now, custom key signatures are clef-specific.
In reply to It's not a bug; you need to by Marc Sabatella
How and where to add KS for other clefs? I have only G clef available, and I don't know how to edit it.
In reply to It's not a bug; you need to by Marc Sabatella
BTW, the staff lines are not those that should be keyed, but notes. Equivalently, G-major doesn't show A# in the bass clef, doesn't it?
If the pitches are defined, than this would be the way to make it work.
Maybe you should keep the ability to change it in this way (example of raga keys of enharmonic pitches in different octaves), but keying must always be of the pitches, across all registers. Therefore the name - key.
In reply to BTW, the staff lines are not by edizioneo
Yes, eventually it needs to become smarter. Especially if it's to ever affect playback. For now, though, it really is just position-based. So ignore the clef in the dialog and create separate key signatures for each clef you plan to use.