A more friendly note/rest erase tool

• Nov 30, 2013 - 15:33

I suggest something like the Finale note eraser tool. You simply click on it, and can click in each individual note or rest to delete. Currently, the Backspace and Delete keys are used to delete notes from score. This shortcuts are very problematics and have odd behavior. (The backspace have a strange bug that sometimes undo actions instead delete the previous notes)


Comments

Can you describe the "odd behavior" or whatever bug you have seen in more detail? I find these keys work exactly as they are documented to work, and don't see how needing to switch to another tool and then presumably back again is ever easier than simply pressing Delete.

In reply to by Marc Sabatella

The bug is about the backspace. In the manual, the shortcut for Undo is Alt+Backspace or Ctrl+Z and only Backspace for erase notes (yes, it´s a perfect and very useful tool for me). The problem is that sometimes when you press only backspace, the MS undo actions instead erase the notes. For me it´s a "strange" behavior. About the delete key, if you want to delete a single note, it´s right, but become boring when you have a lot of individual notes (not the entire staves) in different staves.

(click and delete, click and delete, so many times.... why not only one click? well, it´s just a suggestion, not a critic.) .

In reply to by jeff.leadmann

... 'click and delete, click and delete so many times', try this for erasing multiple notes:
Holding the 'Ctrl' key down, click on several notes to highlight them -- then hit delete once. (Although why not make corrections simply by overwriting the wrong notes?)

As far as a rest erase tool is concerned, be aware that rests in MuseScore should be regarded as temporal placeholders - either for a note; or another (longer/shorter) rest. That's why a rest appears when a note is deleted.
Deleting a measure, or measures, is about the only way to actually 'delete' rests (i.e. make time disappear).

These forums have many discussions regarding MuseScore compared to Finale and Sibelius. A search will make for interesting reading.
Regards...

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.