MusicXML export/import and data loss
Hi,
MuseScore (v.2.2.1 and earlier) exporting MusicXML does not use attribute placement="above/below" in elements like `` and all the articulations (eg. accent, staccato, tenuto etc.`) , and it would be nice to have that information in *.musicxml file.
There's also problem with beaming - I can export MusicXML file correctly (all the atributes are there), but when I import the same file beaming is different.
Test data:
Original score: ms-test1.mscz, ms-test1.png
MusicXML file: ms-test1.musicxml (correct beaming, but slurs and articulations possitioned differently)
Re-import to MuseScore: ms-test2.mscz, ms-test2.png (beaming off)
Another export to MusicXML: ms-test2.musicxml (slurs, articulations and beaming does not work)
What's more, when you import last file again to MuseScore, beaming is even more off...
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| ms-test1.png | 14.44 KB |
| ms-test1.mscz | 3.71 KB |
| ms-test1.musicxml | 5.73 KB |
| ms-test2.png | 15.52 KB |
| ms-test2.mscz | 3.76 KB |
| ms-test2.musicxml | 5.66 KB |
Comments
See #264595: [MusicXML Export] of lyric lines with placement "above" is not correctly created, #229556: Slur placement="below" not saved in MusicXML export and #21435: [MusicXML] always export Slur placement
I forgot to write, that in earlier version (2.1.0) beaming worked fine.