MS4 and .mscx
I am happily exploring MS4 now (great job Martin & everyone!), and am not sure about current or planned support for saving a score as an .mscx (uncompressed MuseScore) file.
I've checked the MS4 manual and the forum post titled "MuseScore 3 features not implemented in MuseScore 4" (https://musescore.org/en/node/334701) and didn't see a mention of this.
In the app, I see the "Save as" dialog has a choice for "Uncompressed MuseScore folder (experimental)", so I assume this has something to do with trying to implement an uncompressed file feature, but I'm not clear if it can be successfully used. My testing so far has given me "corrupted file" errors when I try to open a file that's been "rezipped" into an mscz file after being unzipped, even when no edits to the internal .mscx file were made.
Anyone had success doing minor manual edits to an .mscx file after unzipping the original .mscz file?
Any further info on this?
I'm extensively using the MSCX format and wonder if it's planned to remove it
In reply to Any further info on this? I… by bersyl91
Is there some advantage to the uncompressed format?
In reply to Is there some advantage to… by bobjp
Easy to version control it by e.g. using Git
In reply to Easy to version control it… by Jojo-Schmitz
Precisely ;-) It's the main reason for me.
In reply to Precisely ;-) It's the main… by bersyl91
in Mu4 the mscz contains more that just the mscx (and the thumbnail), as the style is now separated from the score and also the view- and audion settings. And every excerpt, with it's set of files, so you'd have to version control a whole set of files
In reply to in Mu4 the mscz contains… by Jojo-Schmitz
Well, thank you Jojo-Schmitz.
It's not a good news for me as I'll have to re-edit and save all my 1500 scores :-(
But I understand and respect the choice to separate content and appearance: it's a good job.
Have a good day!
I'm about to start some projects that I would like to version on git/github – any updates on this would be useful.
I too have a large catalog of prior scores that are saved in MuseScore 3's uncompressed format so that i can use git to version control them. I really don't care about the thumbnails in my version control and am wondering what the minimum set of files is that I need to add to git to be able to successfully reconstitute the score? Is just the mscx file sufficient?
In reply to I too have a large catalog… by christian41
No, in Mu4 it is no longer
In addition to the mscx, the mscz also contains audiosettings.json, viewsettings.json and score_style.mss, and also a folder with an mscx and an mss as well as virewsettings.json for every excerpt.
In addition to the thumbnail, all (optional) images and container.xml, but those were in Mu3 already