More playback issues with Musescore 4
I am finding that playback is so disfunctional for me that I am sticking with M3, although the sound is so much better on M4.
The enclosed score originated in MuseScore 3.
1) When loaded, the score plays correctly. However simply click on the 'repeat loop' button which places markers at the start and end of the score, then playback always breaks back to the start from the end of Bar 11, having played the first two A sections correctly. Setting playback markers in a series of bars always seems to lose the first part of the first note when the repeat starts.
2) I miss the tempo sliders from M3. That being said playback is broken when attempting to change tempo using either score editing or the somewhat hidden tempo change slider. When the playback hits a 'return to the section start' bar, it loops back and misses some bars, and in some cases will simply stop playing notes.
Try changing the tempo on this score to 120% and the playback begins to fail. It's easier to show than describe, so I've done a tiny video, which cannot be uploaded here - however - it's on my public Dropbox @ https://www.dropbox.com/s/51bedk7ng6hv8c8/Musescore4-tempo-fail.mp4?dl=0. You will have to download to see the video properly. The effect appears to be repeatable. and is made worse by increasing the tempo to say 140%.
This is all on an Intel iMac running Catalina (because Apple in their wisdom has deemed my machine to be an antique that's not worth supporting).
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
Coleman's March m4.mscz | 13.2 KB |
Comments
I am going back to MS3 too. Maybe by 2024 they will have fixed this unusably buggy "upgrade."
In reply to I am going back to MS3 too… by Gliese667Cc
Can you explain which what specifically you are referring to? Bugs can't be fixed if they don't get reported. In general it's working fine, there are bugs just as there are in MU3. Both should be completely usable. MU4 will just produce far better results in terms of the engraving and the sound.
In reply to Can you explain which what… by Marc Sabatella
Sorry to butt in.
I fear that I am having the same problems with playback in MU4, as I reported a few months ago. Scratchy, hesitant, wierd changes in tempo and odd echo effects. Opening the mixer makes some improvement (why?). Today a violin concerto suddenly introduced voice sound until I paused the piece and started again. I am regretting MU4 and would prefer to use MU3 but many of my pieces now cannot be read by MU3.
I fear that many of the technical terms within the forum go over my head.
CA
In reply to Sorry to butt in. I fear… by cadams
You can output as MusicXML and read that back into MU3.
I should have said 'export'.
In reply to Sorry to butt in. I fear… by cadams
Or extract the mscx from the mscz with WinZip or 7Zip or the likes and open that in Mu3
In reply to Or extract the mscx from the… by Jojo-Schmitz
That's very useful, Ta. It's also a way of getting MU4 files into the MU3 player on an iPad.
In reply to Sorry to butt in. I fear… by cadams
Did you try changing your audio device sample rate?> That seems to be the most common cause of playback problems mismatches between what your device is set to vs what the OS is reporting to MuseScore. So setting it explicitly (usually to 44.1) normally solves it. The sample rate is normally somewhere in your OS settings, like the properties for the speaker or whatever.
In reply to I am going back to MS3 too… by Gliese667Cc
At the time I posted this, I didn't know about posting bugs on GitHub. This I've done, and the bug has been marked as high priority.
And the bug doesn't exist in MU3.
But here's hoping.
In reply to At the time I posted this, I… by peasea
Here's the link to GitHub.
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/16875#issuecomment-152347…