Triple-dotted notes

• Jul 31, 2015 - 22:11

Comments

Sorry I have taken so long to respond. A friend and I composed and performed a piece for flute and piano a few months back, but it was all on paper and sort of hasty. He finished writing his part out and I wrote mine. I need to put them together for him and I figured that might as well be the first thing I did with MuseScore. I figured out that while I had notated triple-dotted half notes, I had played them quadruple-dotted! The triple-dotted quarter notes were correct, though. I haven't used your suggestions yet, just getting all the notes down so it sounds right to start off, and trying to juggle other projects. But thank you!

In reply to by LuuBluum

A very rare case.

Is it absolutely necessary? ???

I mean, if I wanted something like this from some specific musicians group, Would I need to write it that way? ???

I prefer use tied notes. Just my humble opinion.

In reply to by jotape1960

Absolutely. A triple dotted note is something most musicians see maybe once or twice in a lifetime. The exact same rhythm written using ties is something we see probably many times a day every single day of our lives. It is virtually always better to write rhythms the way people are accustomed to seeing them, and that means, not using triplet dtos - or even double dots, really.

I agree with the sentiment that triple-dotted notes are not particularly readable, and a low priority for Musescore, but I think they are not as rare as you suggest. They occur (badly printed!) in the Polonaise from Arensky's suite no. 2 for two pianos, and also (as I remember; too big to search) in the vocal score of Carmen, both of which I am actively using at the moment.

People say this is a rare occurrence, but I'm trying to transcribe a song that starts notes on the second 16th of every measure. This requires a triple dot on nearly every bass clef note.

In reply to by Ethan Cannoy

The rhythm isn't what's rare; it's the choice to notate it with a triple dot that is. The vast majority of publishers would not use a triple dot but instead a dotted eighth tied to a dotted half to indicate this.

In any case, in the years since this thread was started, support for triple dots has already been added. Just go to Edit / Preferences / Shortcuts to define a shortcut for it.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.