Problem with grace notes
Hello,
I tried the last nightlybuild and I saw a problem on my old score. All my grace notes, semiquaver for french drums scores, are not on the good line.
I write them on the E or C lines, and I save my score. When I open it after, they appears on the F line. (some of them don't move on the C line).
If i create a new score, it is th same problem.
Sorry for my bad very bad english, I hope you can understand.
Thank you.
Comments
Can you post the score you are having problems with and precise step by step instructions to reproduce the problem?
In reply to Can you post the score you by Marc Sabatella
see #85876: breath marks to non-voice 1 notes are placed wrongly, is this the same issue?
Hmm, probably not, sorry for the noise
In reply to see #85876: breath marks to by Jojo-Schmitz
Here is the score. It is an exercice on a french technique that I am rewriting. Normale grace note are not on this line.
In reply to Here is the score. It is an by axel.chagnon
Thanks for the file, but now can give you precise step by step instructions to reproduce the problem? Where hould I add a grace note, exactly - again, step by step- how should I add it?
One thing I can see is that the grace notes already in this score have pitches that are not in your drum set. For instance, if you click either of the grace notes in the second full measure (measure 3) and then look at the status line, they report that they have no pitch. if I delete that grace note and add it back by clicking the note and either pressing "/" or double clicking the palette icon, it works fine, and then if I save and reload, it still works fine.
So something about the specific way you added that grace note appears to be the problem, which is why wee need precise step by step isntructions to follow in order to udnerstand what went wrong.
In reply to Thanks for the file, but now by Marc Sabatella
Ok I try to explain:
I create a new score. I chose drumset and I load my configuration 'Tambour 5lignes.drm' (attachement files). I write note and grace note, like in the picture. I save and I quit Musecore. When I want to finish, I load the score, and the grace note a not on their places like in the other score I attached.
I had no problem in old version of Nightlybuild.
In reply to Ok I try to explain: I create by axel.chagnon
The part I need you to explain is *how* you are adding the notes. The exact sequence of keys you press or buttons you click. Because again, when I try adding a grace note to your score, it works perfectly. For example:
1) load the score you attached
2) click the very first note of the piece
3) press "/" to add a grace note
4) save
5) close the score
6) open the score
Result: the grace note is exactly where it is supposed to be.
If you follow the above steps *precisely*, does it work correctly for you? If so, then I assume the reason you are having problems is that you are doing something different - not necessarily wrong, but different - in how you are adding your grace notes. I need to know what is different. So I need you to list the steps you are following just as precisely as I just did.
In reply to The part I need you to by Marc Sabatella
Oh, excuse me, I did't understand.
I click on the big note, it is blue, and after I click twice on the grace note. After I chosse the position with the arrow on my key.
In reply to Oh, excuse me, I did't by axel.chagnon
Getting closer, but still - which note do you click, then how many times do you press the arrow key after adding the grace note? My guess is you are somehow changing the grace note to something that is not in your drum set, and that is the source of the problem.
In reply to Getting closer, but still - by Marc Sabatella
I make a video. I just click once on arrows to change tue grace notes place.
https://app.box.com/s/v0rdgpmq4awizo49sxgn0sxyb8dliqad
I hope this is good for you.
Thx !
EDIT : Video is good with Windows MEdia Player, not really with an other... :/
In reply to Getting closer, but still - by Marc Sabatella
I'm on Linux and can't view the video, but maybe someone else can and then write up the step by step instructions.
OK, I have figured out a way to reproduce the problem, and have filed it to the issue tracker - #85956: Note on drum staff moved via arrow key changes pitch on save / reload. It affects notes moved via the arrow keys, whether grace notes or not.
In reply to OK, I have figured out a way by Marc Sabatella
When I click twice on the grace note to create it, after chooe on with big note (in blue) I place it, I use arrow down for the grace note on the upper line, and arrow down for the grace note in the down.
I save and that's all. When I load, grace note places are modified.
In reply to When I click twice on the by axel.chagnon
Yes, thank you, I do understand now.
I have a fix for the problem that I reported as #85956: Note on drum staff moved via arrow key changes pitch on save / reload. If you click that link and subscribe to the issue, you will be notified when the fix has been merged (meaning it will appear in the next nightly build after that).
In reply to Yes, thank you, I do by Marc Sabatella
Cool, thank you very much !:) And very sorry for my bad english :p