Musescore 3.5 D.S. repeats do not work
D.S. repeats are not properly playing back in the current build of MuseScore 3.5 (OS: Windows 10 (10.0), Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.5.0.13199, revision: 43c5553). With repeats on and the "play repeats" box on the D.S. al Fine text inspector checked no repeats and no jumps back to Segno are played, it just plays directly from start to finish.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| segno bug.png | 57.68 KB |
| Segno_Bug.mscz | 5.59 KB |
Comments
Where's the Fine?
It it is supposed to be at the end, a normal D.S. does the trick, as does adding a Fine to the last measure.
Not a bug, but a user error
In reply to Where's the Fine? by Jojo-Schmitz
D.S. al Fine from my experience doesn't need "Fine" in text, as "Fine" also refers to the final barline. Attached below is a screenshot from "Behind Bars" by Elaine Gould explaining this, and I'll also provide a link to another website describing this. https://www.liveabout.com/d-s-al-fine-definition-2701446#:~:text=al%20F….)
I would maintain that this is a bug or a programming error if not a bug.
In reply to D.S. al Fine from my… by sihplak
D.S. al Fine needs a Fine. With MuseScore that it.
A Fine (at least to me and to MuseScore) always means some measure not at the end of the score (but yes, usually with a final barline).
If you mean D.S. (go to segne, play till end o score), just write D.S.
Where exactly does Elaine Gould say otherwise?
Ah, I see you images shows page 238.
She writes:
Add the phrase [I] Fine (’to the end’) to the above terms when the end of the
piece (indicated Fine) is not at the written end of the music.
Exactly what MuseScore does
In reply to D.S. al Fine needs a Fine… by Jojo-Schmitz
How does one enter a Segno? I see the menu, but it just doesn't respond.
In reply to How does one enter a Segno?… by jmrozendaal
See https://musescore.org/en/handbook/3/repeats-and-jumps
In reply to D.S. al Fine from my… by sihplak
If you insist on using DS al Fine rather than DS, put a Fine in the final measure and make it invisible so MuseScore will accept what you did. You can also edit the text of a DS and add "al Fine" to it so MuseScore will not expect a fine. This is a feature of the flexibility of MuseScore not a bug.
In reply to If you insist on using DS al… by mike320
Even when you add the Fine, the DS does not jump back to the Segno.
In reply to Even when you add the Fine,… by underquark
It does for me. Sounds like you probably have a problem with #308698: Continuous view stops repeats from working in playback
In reply to If you insist on using DS al… by mike320
Or replace 'fine' from the jump markers in the inspector for the "D.S. al Fine" with 'end'