Problems with Playback
I am working on the following multi-movement work in MuseScore 2.0.1 on Windows 8.1. For some reason, when I attempt to use the playback on the third movement (the one in 12/8 time), the program won't playback. It's not an issue with soundfonts as every other piece I have works at the start of any movement, but for some reason this one won't. I have tried removing the section break, replacing it with other breaks, making no break at all, and no matter what I do it.
I believe the problem is the "Da Capo al Fine" in the previous movement, as this has happened before with other pieces. I have tried replacing the Da Capo with a "ds al fine," but it still doesn't work. But it works when I take it out.
So I have two questions:
(1) Is this a bug that needs to get worked out or just a problem MuseScore 2.0.1 has with multi-movement pieces?
(2) If the problem is on my end, does anyone have a fix?
Thanks
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
Op. 10 Cello Sonata No 1.mscz | 36.7 KB |
Comments
The "Da Capo al Fine" does seem to be the problem indeed. More specifically, the Fine. MuseScore is taking you too literally, I think. Fine means that's the end, and nothing else plays back. As far as MuseScore is concered, there is nothing else to play. Probably there should be a way for it to understand the next movement - anything after a section break - really comes next.
You could use a D.C. al Coda, modify the jump target of "code" to "fine" and place a Coda at the 1st measure of the next section (and make it invisible)
Or just modify the empty jump target of the D.C. al Fine to "codab" and add that Coda?
In reply to You could use a D.C. al Coda, by Jojo-Schmitz
Thank you for mentioning this. I used to do this in my pieces, in fact, for the same reason, but it had been so many years I had forgotten this technique.
In reply to Thank you for mentioning by Alex N.
This seems to be a bug though, those.special marks "start" and "end" should really refer to the section rather than the score. Mind to create an issue for it?
In reply to This seems to be a bug by Jojo-Schmitz
Also, hitting a Fine should automatically jump to the next section (and reset the state such that repeats are honored as if no DC had taken place.
In reply to Also, hitting a Fine should by Marc Sabatella
I have created an issue for this problem here: https://musescore.org/en/node/65161