Tie problem
Hi guys.
I have problem with tie in the chords or "two notes playing at the same time" (i have no idea how it is in english :)). When I'm trying to tie each note separatly I'm getting something like this (pic attached). 1st note after tie is disappearing, and the 2nd is staying. Do i doing something wrong? Sorry for my bad English.
Thx for help in adv.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| MS1.jpg | 37.23 KB |
Comments
I wasn't getting exactly the same results as you but I did have trouble adding ties to chords in version 0.9.4.
As a workaround add both chords to the score, leave note entry ("N"), and then add the ties.
In reply to I wasn't getting exactly the by David Bolton
It's working. Thx very much.
In reply to I wasn't getting exactly the by David Bolton
I'm having a problem in 0.9.5 with tying chords that I did NOT have in 0.9.4:
In 0.9.5, if I tie a chord to another chord, MuseScore "re-triggers" the notes that aren't tied together. In 0.9.4 (and with written music), you only have to draw one tie line to indicate that the entire chord should be tied. In MuseScore 0.9.5, I have to draw tie lines between each individual note in the chord to get it to sound correct. So, a 3-note chord requires 3 tie lines for MuseScore to sound it correctly.
Has anyone else noticed this? Is there a workaround?
Edit: I've attached an illustration of what I'm talking about.
Edit 2: After looking into it more, I've noticed that some music ties all notes in a chord together, and some doesn't.. But apparently, it's not wrong to tie individual notes. If anybody knows more about this, I'd like to hear it--I'm a self-taught musician, so I'm going based on what I've seen in sheet music.
In reply to Tie problem with 0.9.5 by mass_konfuzion
I am proffessional musician, and all my life i was learn to tie all notes in chord.
In reply to Tie problem with 0.9.5 by mass_konfuzion
As Polish mentions above, a tie is required for every note in the chord. This is a standard rule of music notation. I don't think that this has changed between 0.9.4 and 0.9.5.
In reply to As Polish mentions above, a by David Bolton
Ok, maybe I just wasn't paying attention, but I did write a score using 0.9.4 that played the chords the way I would have expected them to sound, without having to tie each note. But thanks--I learned something :-D
In reply to Tie problem with 0.9.5 by mass_konfuzion
I get the same problem as you do. What happens is, I tie a chord to another chord, but it only ties together the individual notes I tied. While if I only wanted to print out, this would be no problem, I also want to hear it to check it, so it's annoying if it plays out the notes that I DIDN'T tied. This is some kind of bug that should be fixed.
In reply to Same by louis058
louis058, For the workaround see my first comment in this thread: http://musescore.org/en/node/1123#comment-1945
In reply to For the workaround see my by David Bolton
Yeah, I add the ties afterwards, but it's annoying have to add one for every individual note in the chord when one should be enough to tie both chords together. I generally tie the notes together, then make the extra tie(s) invisible.
In reply to I know by louis058
In standard music notation, one tie is not enough to indicate that the whole chord is tied. The only MuseScore bug is you need to leave note entry to add all the ties.
In reply to In standard music notation, by David Bolton
You're right... Goodness sake, so many years learning music and I haven't noticed that.
In a related sense, it would be awesome if there could be a way to tie every note from a chord at once, instead of having to get to each individual note head. I've been inputting a lot of piano music, where I was frequently having to choose all 3 or 4 notes and tie them each. So... additional feature request :)