Can I make a volta into a Fine?
Reported version
3.0
Type
Functional
Severity
S5 - Suggestion
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
I found this odd notation. At the end of the form, there is a "DS al Fine". The song goes through Volta 1 the first time but, after the "DS al Fine", it goes to the "Fine" volta and ends. Is this supported? I can render it (visually) by renaming a Volta 2 to Fine, but how can I get it played?
I think I can easily change it in a Coda, but I was trying to be faithful to the original.
Comments
voltas are pretty pointless without a (set of) corresponding repeat barline(s)
Yes, I'm just trying to reproduce some old-style forms. In the author's mind, I believe the jump (DS al Fine) counted as the repeat.
This is my first post - thank you all for your ongoing MuseScore efforts!
My goal is to produce a bass vocal practice score that is true to the published score (which we all have.) This one cam up in Missa Criolla Kyrie.
Similar to Diego, I am having problems with a "Fine" within a volta - pretty much the same structure posted by Diego:
A (segno) B [Volta1] || [Volta2 incl "Fine"] || C (incl. DS al Fine at end)
Should play:
A B Volta1 C B Volta2
An interesting observation is that if Volta2 is open, playing stops at Volta1.
When Volta2 is closed, it is skipped, and the "Fine" is apparently missed (plays to end of score).
The attached file demonstrates the volta-closed behavior.
So what you really want it to play like this the attached.
In reply to So what you really want it… by Jojo-Schmitz
That's not quite right, since your version plays:
A B C Volta1 B C Volta2
Need to play:
A B Volta1 C B Volta2
In reply to So what you really want it… by Jojo-Schmitz
Sorry - I just realized my "Row Your Boat" example is not representative, since section C is actually unique in Misa Coriolla.
Section C should only play once...
In reply to This is my first post -… by GrouseHiker
This remains an issue. Is this a current limitation of MuseScore?
like this?
In reply to like this? by Jojo-Schmitz
jojo-Schmitz - Thanks for your efforts... My problem is this endeavor is based on producing a bass vocal practice score (playback captured in a video) that matches the published score so the bass singers are looking at what they will see during the performance. I'm gathering the published score (with Segno jump rather than repeat and "Fine" within Volta 2) will not play back in the current Muse Score...
Is this worthy of adding to the "wish list."
Not a bug, at best a missing feature
I believe we have been misinterpreting this issue. As a test, I moved the "Fine" into Volta 1, and play stopped - the "Fine" inside a Volta IS recognized. The real problem is that Volta 2 is never played. Maybe the Volta count doesn't get incremented in a jump (versus a repeat). I will start a different thread, since this is a different issue from the original post.
This is not an issue with a "Fine" within a Volta. It is an issue with Volta2 play within a "Jump" vs a "repeat." See https://musescore.org/en/node/283275.
Or #283275: Volta 2 not played in a "Jump" (vs. a "Repeat")