Cresc. marking resulting in immediate increase in volume
At bar 103, the cresc. mark results in an immediate, large increase in volume. (Note: there is a similar multi-bar cresc. poco a poco at bar 27 which behaves normally.)
OS: macOS 10.15, Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.4.2.25137, revision: 148e43f, Qt version 5.9.8.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Songs_for_Pianoforte,_1836-7.mscz | 45.92 KB |
Comments
The p in measure 72 is attached to the bottom staff (but moved to above it), but still set to affect the entire instrument. That cresc. though is attached tio the top staff (and set to affect the entire instrument too), this seems to confuse MuseScore. Possible workarounds:
In reply to The p in measure 72 is… by Jojo-Schmitz
Thank you for the workarounds, but should I submit this as a big? (The fact that you're describing the solutions as workarounds rather than as corrections of my use kind of implies "yes.")
In reply to Thank you for the… by OlyDLG
Not even sure it is a real bug
Hmm, guess it is...
In reply to Not even sure it is a real… by Jojo-Schmitz
Well, I'll submit it and let the developers decide.
In reply to The p in measure 72 is… by Jojo-Schmitz
Oh, and that doesn't sound like it must have been easy to diagnose, so thanks!
And did you reproduce the problem on a non-Mac platform (so that I can report it as a cross-platform bug if "yes.")
In reply to Oh, and that doesn't sound… by OlyDLG
Windows 7.
In reply to The p in measure 72 is… by Jojo-Schmitz
That did fix the problem at bar 103--thanks! However: I was experiencing the same problem, or so I thought, at bar 165, and the same workaround didn't appear to fix it, so I was all ready to "complain" and seek further assistance/advice, when, on a hunch, I checked to see if the accents concurrent w/ the initiation of the cresc. molto were to blame and sure enough they were. So then I was hoping to lessen--but not eliminate--their impact, but there doesn't appear to be any velocity change control for accents; so the only workaround I can think of is to immediately precede-and-hide the cresc. molto with a p (one dynamic level lower than the immediately preceding active dynamic level) and then fine tune that if/as necessary: any other suggestions? Thanks again!
In reply to That did fix the problem at… by OlyDLG
That is an adequate workaround for my taste, but I'd still be interested in getting feedback on this.
New issue created 3/25/20 w/ minor severity and cross-reference to this thread.