Minimum stave distance
1. Open attached score (produced in 1.3).
2. Drag the bottom stave up.
Result: The clef collides with the stave above.
Discussion: Should we have an improved minimum stave distance that avoids collisions with clefs?
Using MuseScore 2.0 Nightly Build (93ee3c9) - Mac 10.7.5.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Minimum stave distance.mscz | 1.35 KB |
| Minimum stave distance.png | 22.84 KB |
Comments
I think if the user wants staves that cose together, he should be able to get it. And if he doesn't want want staves that close together, he shouldn't drag them that close. In general, I can't see anyone complaining "musescore let me do X", but I can always see someone cmplainng "musescore *won't* let me do X". So unless there is really an strong reason to disallow something that already works, I can't see any reason to arbitrarily mode limits.
In reply to I think if the user wants by Marc Sabatella
So clear. Yeah.
I'm sure once more automation is implemented, it maybe less necessary to adjust.
However, what is the point of allowing the clefs to collide?
In reply to I'm sure once more automation by chen lung
First, with other clefs such as bass clef, or if the clefs are invisible, there is no collision. It's obviously not an traditional notatio, but then, neither are a lot of things MuseScore has to go out itsway to support. Here, it already works. If you want staves that d that, you can get it. Again, what purpose does it serve to tell people who want to do this that they aten't allowed to? How does that help anyone at all?
In reply to First, with other clefs such by Marc Sabatella
If it was for purposes such as the ones you suggest, then fair enough :).