Invisible dynamics affects auto place
as in here:
when the hairpins on the second phrase should look like:
Obviously there's a workaround in this particular instance - I've got rests to play with - but that is not always true.
as in here:
when the hairpins on the second phrase should look like:
Obviously there's a workaround in this particular instance - I've got rests to play with - but that is not always true.
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
I don't completely understand #277367: invisible notes and rests remain part of the skyline, but it might fix the problem.
I've seen what you are talking about mentioned before and thought it was in a bug report, but I could be wrong. I actually though I submitted a bug report.
In reply to I don't completely… by mike320
Looks like they fixed that months ago, though, it's crossed out and everything, so presumably the Beta includes that commit?
In reply to Looks like they fixed that… by Laurelin
It was fixed 5 hours ago, at least that's when the message was posted.
In reply to I don't completely… by mike320
That fix doesn't affect this particular issue. The "skyline" is about the height of staves, how high things need to be moved above or below to clear other things. So, for instance, put a staff text and a rehearsal mark on the same beat, the rehearsla mark jumps above hide the staff text, the rehearsal mark now jumps back down - that's what that fix was about. Horizontal placement of elements is different, and unfortunately that change didn't affect this. A different issue would need to be submitted.
BTW, workaround could be to uncheck "Automatic placement" for the hairpin, although in some cases you might want it for other reasons (eg, to avoid the dynamic afterwards).
In reply to That fix doesn't affect this… by Marc Sabatella
IMHO, everything invisible should be ignored by auto placement. That would solve the problem.