request independent lyric placement per staff

• Feb 10, 2019 - 03:12
Reported version
3.0
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S5 - Suggestion
Reproducibility
Always
Status
active
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project

I would like to be able to set lyric placement (above or below) independently per staff. My reason for wanting this feature pertains to when I write for accordion and voice. Accordion left hand notation is particular in the sense that text markings are used for chords. Left hand has single bass buttons as well as chord buttons, so in accordion notation notes with no markings indicate single bass notes, and notes with markings indicate which chord button (note) and chord type (marking). The Musescore 3.0 file I uploaded is an excerpt where you can see how accordion left hand is notated. For this I use lyric entry, with placement set as above (via Format - Style... - Lyrics). Now I'm aware that my excerpt shows Bb trumpet as a melody instrument, but if it were a vocal line with lyrics, then I would like to be able to place lyric placement below melody notes, as standard practice. Would I be able to use lyric placement above for left hand accordion chord markings, as well as lyric placement below for a vocal melody line? Thank you for your input.

Attachment Size
Add One - excerpt.mscz 12.13 KB

Comments

Since these aren't lyrics, I would recommend not using lyrics for this. As of 3.0.2, you can use Alt+Right while entering other text to get similar navigation. I'd recommend using staff text or some other element type instead.

In reply to by Marc Sabatella

Hi Marc, thanks for the suggestion. Can you better explain the Alt+Right navigation? I'm interpreting what you're saying as that once I put a staff text associated with a note, I can stay in text mode and navigate to the next note using Alt+Right. However I'm not able to do this. This would be awesome as my workflow would be just like lyric mode - stay in text and go note to note: instead of clicking on a note, clicking staff text, clicking in the text box to write text, and then doing these 3 steps again for each note.

While editing a text element (don't hit Esc when finished), press Alt+Right, and you can then immediately enter new text on the next note, same as Space (or Alt+right) does while entering lyrics. So there would be no more advantage to misusing lyrics for things that are not actually lyrics any more.

This assumes you have the current version of MuseScore - 3.0.2.

In reply to by Marc Sabatella

Hi Marc, thanks again. Ok, so I tried that and Alt+Right is still not taking me to the next note element (I'm not pressing Esc, I'm staying in text edit mode using Staff Text). I'm using version 3.02.20666, rev. 8ca4d2c on Mac. To test, I tried the Alt+Right in Lyrics mode (which I didn't know about by the way, I was always using Space and Shift+Space), and that works.

For Mac it is probably Option instead of Alt? Or maybe something with Fn. The same shortcut should alsowork while note in text edit mode, just to navigate through the score. It won't just go note by note but will also visit text and other markings.

In reply to by Marc Sabatella

Thanks Marc, I've been playing around and haven't figured out the key combination yet. I'll keep at it. But the fact that Alt+Right worked in Lyric mode and isn't working for text elements makes me wonder if the software mod didn't quite make it to Mac. I'll keep playing around and let you know. Thank you so much for your time.

In reply to by HotChocolateJazz

I got it! There was no combination working. Then I decided to browse Preferences and discovered the Shortcuts tab. There I noticed there were no shortcuts defined for Accessibility: Next element and Accessibility: Previous element. So I defined Alt (same thing as Option) + Right and Alt+Left respectively. Now it works great!

In reply to by HotChocolateJazz

I'd also like to add one more thing. Using Staff Text is way better, not just for the reason you gave me (unintended use of Lyrics), but this text edit mode adapts to vertical element position instead of fixed vertical height; thus respecting usual aesthetic for left hand chord notation. I attached an image file to show a standard example. Thank you very much for your time Marc!

Attachment Size
Screen Shot 2019-02-10 at 18.51.28.png 64.8 KB