Crashes on XML Import
I am using logic Pro to auto-generate scores for my piano and then import them over to musescore. For some reason on this song I can't, and it crashes directly on import. Any help? I have to finish scoring this tonight, so please try to help if you can! I am on a macbook.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| mylegacy.xml | 738.35 KB |
Comments
I can tell you the issue seems to involve a bad tuplet in or around measure 18, maybe that will help you work around it.
In reply to I can tell you the issue… by Marc Sabatella
Thank you so much! Musescore should display a prompt showing what the problem is instead of just crashing. I just redid that measure in Logic and it seems to be working well now. Again, thank you, I don't know what I would have done without you!
In reply to Thank you so much! Musescore… by johannovak7
So I take it that allowed you to continue? Glad to hear it if so!
For the record, we do produce error messages for all errors we are able to anticipate and detect. But unfortunately, you can't anticipate every possible error condition. We don't plan to crash, but that's what happens to any program when it encountered errors it wasn't designed to handle. There are all sorts of errors involving tuplets we do detect and deal with, but whatever is going on here must be something that has never been seen before.
Had a quick look. For me (using 3.6 devel) it crashes in measure 19, on the note starting at line 10568.
Will submit an issue, as MuseScore preferably should not crash, even if it encounters incorrect input.
Don't know the exact cause yet.
Cause found, created issue #313351: [MusicXML import] crash when importing file with duplicate voice containing tuplet with rest.
Note: the attached file contains two identical copies of voice 1, which may be incorrect and should be reported to the developers of Logic Pro.