Dynamics not behaving as intended 🤔🤔
Hi Musescore community, so the problem I have, I'm not sure if there's already posts about it (I tried looking it up, but I couldn't find any answers), but it's as the title suggests, Dynamics don't behave as intended.
I have an example piece I made with Hot Cross Bun demonstrating the bug right here: https://musescore.com/user/37685924/scores/13759702
I've observed this bug to affect instruments that have both Bass Clef and Treble Clef, where the dynamic of the opposite staff would be affected by setting the dynamics of 1 staff (not both). I'm terrible at explaining things, so I hope that my example above can help me describe what I'm trying to explain.
Thanks you in advance!
Comments
I guess that has not yet been implemented. We are supposed to be be able to have different dynamics on Grand Staff instruments...sometime.
You can post your mscz file here rather than on the .com site.
In reply to I guess that has not yet… by bobjp
I don't understand what you mean by posting it here, do you mean I should upload sheet music here instead of .com, or attaching the mscz file here?
Well, here "as intended" is exactly what they are doing as currently the dynamic is applied to an instrument or a part and the piano(or harp, marimba, organ etc.) is treated as a single instrument. It might not be what you want but it isn't a bug as such.
In reply to Well, here "as intended" is… by underquark
I see 👍
In reply to Well, here "as intended" is… by underquark
" It might not be what you want but it isn't a bug as such."
Agreed, it's not a bug because it was implemented as a deliberate decision for MS4.
But is is a regression, because separate dynamics for a great stave (grand staff) worked perfectly in MS versions up to and including MS3.