concert orchestra template
I just downloaded MuseScoreNightly-2017-01-05-1549-master-73a2e6a.7z
and started a new score and clicked on the concert orchestra template. It opened fine with the right instruments but the barlines were not consitent concert orchestra template.svg. (you'll have to zoom out) Just wondering if thats worth the time to adress?
Comments
Do you mean the barlines extending from flute 1 to flute 2 but not extending from Oboe 1 to Oboe 2 and so forth?
In reply to Do you mean the barlines by mike320
yes.
deleted
It should be consistent.
There have been some changes in barline handling, the templates will need to be updated for this and other reasons. Probably makes sense to wait until things stabilize a bit more before worrying about this, though.
In reply to There have been some changes by Marc Sabatella
Stil this seems to indicate a problem with importing 2.x scores (all the templates are 2.x scores), doesn't it? So yes, the templates all need to get updated one day, but also the way how 2.x scores get imported.
This is a recent change that I'm very strongly opposed to and has not been explained yet: #153106: Restore functionality of extending barline through multiple staves in one go
In reply to This is a recent change that by Isaac Weiss
Not quite the same problem, connecting 2 staves should still work, and that's what is asked for here, isn't it?
In reply to Not quite the same problem, by Jojo-Schmitz
No—if you compare the SVG with the template in 2.0.3 or 2.1, you'll see that the barlines are supposed to extend through the exact same staves as the thick brackets cover.
In reply to No—if you compare the SVG by Isaac Weiss
Yes that's what they did in 2.x. In 3.0 you still can have them pair-wise. As per Werner this is by design...
In reply to Yes that's what they did in by Jojo-Schmitz
Per Werner the functionality change is by design, but how could that engraving possibly be by design?
In reply to No—if you compare the SVG by Isaac Weiss
concert-orch-1.svg
In reply to [inline:concert-orch-1.svg] by Isaac Weiss
Stil possible
In reply to Stil possible by Jojo-Schmitz
Right—possible with many, many small steps, and no longer possible with a single double-click and drag or a single Inspector change.
In reply to Right—possible with many, by Isaac Weiss
And just a one-time change for a template
In reply to And just a one-time change by Jojo-Schmitz
Yes, but people also choose instruments to create their own scores.
In reply to Yes, but people also choose by Isaac Weiss
Correct Isaac. The limitation being contemplated on bar lines makes no sense.
What about adding a "barlines span to next staff" to the staff properties (editor)? When adding instruments in 3.0 you can choose the staff style type for every instrument, so it should easily be possible to create a staff style "connected to next staff" or "staff group". Perhaps also adding a bracket or brace to a group of staffs could trigger the barlines span to next staff for these staffs (except the last one).