Import of chord symbols from MIDI XF doesn't work

• Feb 4, 2017 - 15:47
Reported version
3.0
Type
Functional
Severity
S4 - Minor
Status
closed
Project

The import of chord symbols from midi files doesn't work in version 3.0.0 ref: 101541c (not yet implemented?)

See the differences in the pictures below (screenshot of 2.0.3 and the actual nightly build of 3.0.0)

refers to: https://musescore.org/en/node/39511

Attachment Size
Swing low.MID 1.29 KB
chordsymbols203.png 58.6 KB
chordsymbols3.png 51.93 KB

Comments

Title Import of chord symbols from midi doesn't work Import of chord symbols from MIDI XF doesn't work

Confirmed with c66f162
It never gets to the point in code where those chord symbols are parsed, it leaves MidiChordName::readChordName() at mscore/Importmidi/Import_midi.cpp, line 104

So whatever we do to fix #167196: import of chord symbols from midi files should correspond with the formal note spelling , it still won't work in master

Attached a test file from our own regression tests (probably disabled currently)

Attachment Size
Chord+Lyric-Test-Midi.mid 2.01 KB