Wrong Midi-Channels when exporting Midi-File
Hello,
when I choose some articulations for different notes,
Musescore 3 doesn't export the Midi-Channels correctly...
For Example:
A Violin played arco (normal) should be Midi-Channel 1, pizzicato (plucked) should be Midi-Channel 2.
If the Track gets exported as a Midifile, all Notes are on Midi-Channel 1.
If the Notes are copied to another track and that one gets exported,
all Notes are on Midi-Track 4.
This bug does only occur in Musescore 3,
in Musescore 2 everything is working as it should.
You'll find all the files (mid + mscz) as attachment.
Thxs a lot, best,
Roman
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Midi-Test.mscz | 6.42 KB |
| Midi-Test-Violine.mid | 208 bytes |
| Midi-Test-Viola.mid | 208 bytes |
Comments
I'm not so sure that's a bug - there is nothing wrong with putting everything on one MIDI channel as long as there are also appropriate program change messages where needed. I don't have a MIDI editor to check, though. Are you sure they are not present?
In reply to I'm not so sure that's a bug… by Marc Sabatella
Hello Marc,
as I wrote: In Musescore 2 evrathing works fine as it should...
The issue only occurs in Musescore 3...
If one wants to play back the MIDI-File with any VST (especially a non-GM-VST), different MIDI channels are necessary to make different sounds beeing playable on different channels...
Best, Roman
In reply to Hello Marc, as I wrote: In… by Dudo01
As I said, if program changes are present, you don't need different channels. Both will work. So unless you are sure there are no program changes, again, it doesn't sound like a bug to me, just different valid ways of getting the same end result.
In reply to As I said, if program… by Marc Sabatella
I think I have the same problem: I exported my score but there were no program changes or different midi channels for pizzicato and arco. (I thought it is not a feature yet)
In reply to I think I have the same… by Tamás Frank
When I export a violin part that contains a mix or arco and pizz, I get two separate tracks, set to different channels. Can you attach the score you are having problems with, and the MIDI file you got when you tried exporting?
In reply to Hello Marc, as I wrote: In… by Dudo01
I sure hope the issue gets fixed in Musescore 3.
In reply to I sure hope the issue gets… by matthew.sibley.3388
It won't. Hopefully in MuseScore 4
Die Midi-Dateien sind mit MuseScore 2 exportiert worden und tönen anders als die von Dudo01 angehängten Dateien. Der MidiXML-Datei (zip) ist zu entnehmen, dass die Kanäle wie folgt programmiert sind
Kanal1: 40 entspricht "Violin"
Kanal2: 45 entspricht "Pizzicato Strings"
Kanal3: 44 entspricht "Tremolo Strings"
Die Kanäle werden auch so in der MuseScore Version 3 programmiert, aber ohne die Kanal-Umschaltung geht der Effekt verloren.
Ich schreibe das, weil ich den Eindruck habe, Marc sehe das nicht als Fehler.
In reply to Die Midi-Dateien sind mit… by jmueller5524
Ich habe es mit diversen Versionen (3.4.2_backend, 3.5.2_backend, 3.6.2.backend und 3.x) überprüft, mit keiner konnte ich einen fehlerhaften Midi-Export produzieren.