tie mark does not tie notes in muse sound violin solo1

• Dec 21, 2023 - 12:50

ties do not tie notes in this instrument

Attachment Size
un_tie.mscz 17.72 KB

Comments

... there is a difference between "tied" and "separate". But even with a tie I can still hear a very slight interruption, like a change of bowing direction. Maybe that is a deliberate implementation feature?

In reply to by 77humus

BTW. This forum is for us users to post problems we have. Sometimes these issues are just user error. Sometimes they are software problems. once it can be agreed that there is a software problem, then the user escalates it to GitHub. That where developers will see it.

In reply to by Marc Sabatella

removing the tie, of course, you will hear the clear note separation. adding it you still hear that separation in a subtle way. as i said, not matter the value of the notes tied the violin solo 1 will separate them. that is not the meaning and function of tie mark. the solo violin 2 and viola solo do not separate the notes, showing that the violin 1 has a bug in that feature. that is not a natural variation, that would be a bad technique if a violinist would not be able to tie notes imperceptibly...

I think it might be the bowing effect. You cannot hold a note forever, so string players change bow direction subtly to fix this. So does Muse Sounds. Of course, players could do a better job. The bow change might have just been at the wrong spot.

In reply to by Asher S.

i do not think that is the case here, mainly because this error happens with any value note ( whole, half, a note extending many bars). e. g. in a 3/4 bar having a half plus a quarter tied, the violin plays both notes. the bow has a lot more endurance than that. furthermore, there is a bow technique in which is possible to change the direction without interruption. also, the violin has no right to decide when to ignore the tie indication, lol.

In reply to by 77humus

OK. I don't think it is a case of solo 1 "ignoring" the tie. But it isn't quite playing it correctly. When I play the example several times, there can be a difference in playback.
As for a real player ignoring a tie. They get to do what they feel in the moment.

In reply to by bobjp

what i mean by ignore, is not to perform the correct instruction which is play continuously without any kind of interruption ( nor subtle nor strong). the matter here is that the violin is not executing that instruction. i my self used to play a little of violin and cello and there is no that license for ignoring vital instructions like a tie or the bow being uncapable to play notes of any extent tied. you are supposing that some violinist somewhere decided to change the rules. but here is just a software that should follow the commands for what was programmed.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.