Commercial use of scores
Could somebody clarify something for me in the terms of use? Could a score produced using Musescore be used commercially, e.g. sold in either print or electronic (PDF) format? If not in the free version, can this right be assumed in the pro version?
Comments
There is no separate "pro" version of MuseScore - the free version is already suitable for most professional usage, and indeed, many of us have been using it professionally. Perhaps you are confusing MuseScore (the open source notation software that you use to create scores on your computer) with musescore.com (the score sharing web site where you can upload scores for others to access). There is indeed a Pro account on musescore.com that allows for more scores to be uploaded and provides other advantages. But it's still the same free MuseScore software you'd run on your computer to create those scores.
Anyhow scores created with MuseScore are as much yours to use as scores you create with pencil and paper. That is, if you own the rights to the music itself - your original composition, a public domain source, or something you have legal permission to use in this way - then you are free to sell the sheet music you create. But, just as with pencil and paper, the mere fact that you created the physical score doesn't automatically give you the rights to the music on it if you didn't own that already. So you can't produce your own arrangement of MIchael Jackson's "Thriller" and sell that without permission. That is true of arrangements created with pencil and paper just as it is of arrangements created with MuseScore.
So, maybe that's a good analogy: using MuseScore is no different from using a pencil with respect to your legal rights.
Thank you Marc for that crystal clear explanation. I was in deed confusing Musescore.org with musescore.com. So am I correct to understand that once you create a score on Musescore, to upload it onto the internet you are using the musecore.com website? Or am I being really stupid again!?!
In reply to Re commercial use of scores by Lazar Der Gregorian
You can create a score with MuseScore for free, and do whatever you want with it. Eventually, if you want to publish your score online, on the internet, MuseScore.com is one solution among others, but it's nothing mandatory. It has several advantages. It provides playback, comments, and many more. You can also embed a score you posted on MuseScore.com on another website, like you can do with a youtube video. According to me (and I'm one of the co-founder of Musescore.com), it's the best place on the internet to host your scores :) but it's up to you to decide. Here is an example.
http://musescore.com/nicolas/scores/58388
Note that MuseScore.com is not a way to sell your scores. It's a way to share them. If you want to sell them, you can of course host them on MuseScore.com and use the embed player on your own website but MuseScore.com doesn't provide you with a shop system for your scores.
In reply to You can create a score with by [DELETED] 5
I am creating a piano game on mobile playforms which downloads midi from MuseScore.com website. I dont own the music or the scores basically, I just put the musescore url into my game. Will I have legal issue with copyright?
In reply to I am creating a piano game… by Nhạc Yêu Thích
Could be, better to consult a lawyer.
In reply to Re commercial use of scores by Lazar Der Gregorian
If you use the "Save Online" feautre of MuseScore (under the FIle menu), then yes, that is using musescore.com. You are free to use that or any other site to upload your score to, but as lasconic mentions, musescore.com provides no facility for selling your score, and indeed, scores uploaded there are available for *free*. It's like YouTube or Flickr in that respect - those are not sites where upload things to *sell*, but rather, where you upload things to *share*.
In reply to If you use the "Save Online" by Marc Sabatella
Just to be precise, all scores on MuseScore.com are not available for *free"! You can make your scores private on MuseScore.com and share the link with your customers, after they buy the access from you. You can also have your scores on MuseScore available for free and you can sell it on another website, for example in paper form. So, yes, MuseScore.com is about sharing but you can share the scores stored there the way you want, this way can also be commercial if you want it to be this way but MuseScore.com doesn't provide the payment infrastructure to do so.
In reply to Just to be precise, all by [DELETED] 5
Yes, good point.
Once again thank you all for your responses.
Can you commercially use the audio that comes from MuseScore instruments? Not as in commercially use the samples, but commercially use an original composition that has audio partially or wholly made up of MuseScore instruments?
In reply to Can you commercially use the… by Heliolux
Yes, you may.
You are pretty much free to do whatever you want when it comes to the default MuseScore soundfont. See the full license at https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/blob/master/share/sound/FluidR3M…
This issue regarding who owns what and can it be monetized using Musescore to create it has been bothering me almost from the day I stumbled upon this unbelievable program. The concise nature of the original question, the following reply and the further comments it generated receives high praise for a no BS commentary. So thanks to all involved for your moment of clarity and the focus on subject specifity(?).
In reply to This issue regarding who… by bassoflauto
I have just found a site https://www.pianorarescores.com/ which is selling scores (of public domain music) I have created on musescore without seeking permission from me. I wonder if anyone else has experience of this?
In reply to I have just found a site… by memeweaver
IIRC you're not the first to find that and complain about it.
Sue them.
OTOH: if you put your scores into the Public Domain, they can do withit whatever they like.
With proper Creative Commons license you could exclude commercial use.
In reply to I have just found a site… by memeweaver
Unfortunately this does happen, even with scores which are not public domain and there's very little that we can do about it. If there is a review section on the site selling your score you could share a link to the Musescore upload but, from my experience, these sites are frequently hosting scams so I would steer clear of them. Quite often the copy takes the form of a poorly screenshotted pdf which should put off potential buyers.
Use a Creative Commons licence to stop your scores from being sold on legitimate sites.
In reply to I have just found a site… by memeweaver
From Pianorarescores site:
Copyright Complaints
Pianorarescores respects the intellectual property of others. If you believe that your work has been copied in a way that constitutes copyright infringement, please contact us immediately.