Defining different tablature presets
I hope this topic fits into thie forum, but I don't think it would be correct in feature request, as it mainly handles about the way of using tablature.
I now count at the moment 13 different notation ways and I fear, if we will continue in the current path, there should be much more. We have already
(1-3) 6-string tablature simple & common & full
(4-6) 5-string tablature simple & common & full
(7-9) 4-string tablature simple & common & full
(10) Ukulele
(11) Balalaika
(12) 6-string-italian
(13) 6-string-french
As you can imagine, there also should be 4-string-italian, 4-string-french, 5-string-italian anf 5 string-french, when the historical instruments will be also presented in instruments.xml.
And there also should be a way to notate the Angelique, which has a variated 6-string-french notation.
So that would sum up to (at least) 18 different tablature presets.
That would make the dialogue even more confusing.
Wouldn't it be better to only list the different forms, so to say:
tablature simple
tablature common
tablature full
Ukulele
Balalaika
tablature-italian (historical/lute)
tablature-french (historical/lute)
The number of lines can be set up in the dialogue-box very easily.
But then it would be necessary to have a way to set up the number of lines in instruments.xml
I think, that would help to make things more easy.
Comments
Some more are in the pipeline, see #271103: Add 7-string guitar and Cavaquinho (4-strings guitar) and https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/3618, adding 7- and 8-string common tablature
In reply to Some more are in the… by Jojo-Schmitz
Don't forget the work being done on the Shamesin (https://musescore.org/en/node/270063)
In reply to Don't forget the work being… by mike320
Ah, right. so soon we may grow from the current 13 tablature types to 16
In reply to Some more are in the… by Jojo-Schmitz
To not further clutter the dialog with more and more tablature presets, I've now changed the code of the above mentioned PR to not show those that need more strings than the instrument actually has set up (as non-open)