[LilyPond] Bar lines and repeats appear prematurely
Hi,
when I export to Lilypond format, the bar lines and repeat marks
I insert (from the bar line palette) move and appear one bar too early.
Exporting to MusicXML first and then converting to lilypond format
via musicxml2ly works fine.
MuseScore 1.0 on Ubuntu and Nightly Build r4414 Windows 7 both
show the bug.
I have attached a small example.
Thanks!
dj
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| barline-test.mscz | 1.61 KB |
| barline-test.ly | 2.97 KB |
Comments
To be more accurate, the bar line does appear at the end, but there's a duplicate one in the bar before (see image ).
It's might be hard to know if some bugs are a fault of Lilypond, or MuseScore.
Using MuseScore 1.1 and Lilypond 2.14.2 - Mac 10.6.8.
Actually, it appears twice in the same bar (not in the previous one) - I didn't look at it closely.
After doing some tests, a score with an anacrusis and:
Multi-voice rests - no extra bar line.
Deleted multi-voice rests - extra bar line.
I think any other score has problems.
Also reproduced here with 1.1. Every voice contains final bar line in the penultimate and the last bar.
I also have this problem with Max OSX 10.7.2 and Musescore 1.1 b4611, Lilypond 2.15.22.
Here the files: http://musescore.org/de/node/14746
I have a score which has no multi-voice, but shows this problem.
With Nightly Musescore 2.0 build 5262 most problems disappear. All repeat marks correct, even codas! Only the problem with the doubled end bar remains.
In the LilyPond script, the barline is \bar "|."
Removing it fixes the issue, but it would be nice to have a fix in MuseScore.
The bug is also present in MuseScore 1.2 Revision 5470.
I have confirmed in the Lilypond output source that the problem is on MuseScore's end.
MuseScore also misplaces repeats in LilyPond's output when the repeats are supposed to fall in the middle of a measure.
The attached file "30b.xml" renders fine in the MuseScore interface. Printing it in the MuseScore interface produces the correct output, as shown in "musepdf.pdf". The Lilypond output is shown in "30b.ly" and a PDF copy in "lilypdf.pdf". The LilyPond source clearly shows the repeat beginning and ending in the wrong place, as confirmed by the LilyPond PDF output.
if you really want to use Lilypond for your final output. You should investigate another way. Export in MusicXML and use musicxml2ly, provided with your lilypond install to get a lilypond file. If you want to automate this, check this plugin https://github.com/lasconic/lilypond_export
Thank you, lasconic.
I have looked at musicxml2ly and will probably begin using it. But MuseScore does provide the option of saving a file to LilyPond's format, so my expectation, as a user, is that said option will work. Especially when every other aspect of that export option seems to be fully functional. I appreciate the work-around, but I don't think it's really a solution.
I notice that one of the previous commentors says that this is fixed in MuseScore 2, but the bug is still marked as unresolved. Hence, my visit here.
I installed the 2.0 nightly build (windows) in order to get this problem solved, but the current revision (15c1263 from 2013-03-29) does not even provide a lilypond export possibility.
indeed, LilyPond export has been removed recently, so I guess this is by design.