Trill playback plays all notes (instead of just trilled note)
I know playback isn't a priority necessarily, but I'm just wondering if I'm doing something wrong when I add a trill to a note with other notes at the same time. In the attached example there is a b major chord in the right hand with a trill on the top-most note. However, playback will play the entire chord as a trill, essentially back and forth between a b major and c major chord.
I added the trill by selecting the top note and double clicking the trill in the palette. I searched the forums and can't find anything about this, so I was wondering if it's a known issue or something I did incorrectly.
Thanks!
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Trill.mscz | 7.4 KB |
Comments
In your example you got half way to proper playback. You put the B-natural in another voice, but you kept the trill on the chord. You need to delete the trill, select only the B-natural and enter the trill again.
Trill.mscz
In reply to In your example you got half… by mike320
I think I see the issue - if you select the proper note and use the Trill from the articulation palette, it works properly, however I'm trying to use the Trill from the "Lines" master palette because I require the jagged line after it as well. This doesn't seem to be able to be set to a specific voice. Seems like a bug to me, as one method works but the other doesn't.
In reply to I think I see the issue - if… by Bryan Saylor
To be more clear, see attached. One version has the trill applied from the Articulations & Ornaments palette, and the other from the Lines palette. One plays correctly and the other doesn't.
In reply to To be more clear, see… by Bryan Saylor
So exchange voice 1 and 2 to put only the top B in voice 1, so only it is trilled ;-)
In reply to So exchange voice 1 and 2 to… by Louis Cloete
That probably wont work Even though the trill line is blue like voice 1 it affects notes in all voices like an ottava would.
In reply to So exchange voice 1 and 2 to… by Louis Cloete
Looks like it does work! I'll use this as a workaround, thank you.
In reply to I take it back! Looks like… by Bryan Saylor
Glad I was wrong.
BTW, what you wanted is the expected result of applying a trill.
In reply to I think I see the issue - if… by Bryan Saylor
You are correct about trills lines always being applied to voice 1. I didn't pay attention to the status bar when I deleted your trill, it looked like the one from You can make it look like a trill line and disable playback in the inspector then use the trill from articulations and make it invisible. It's quite the work around but it'll work.
In reply to I think I see the issue - if… by Bryan Saylor
FWIW, the use of the line is considered optional, so I wouldn't assume you "need" it. but if you do want it, another option is to add the articulation than just add a wavy line as a symbol (press "Z" for that palette), or from the Lines palette but disable playback. Or add both trills, mark the articulation one invisible, the line one non-playing.