another volta playback issue
Hi people,
i have been doing a score and ended up discovering weird behavior with voltas in 3.0.
there are pictures of expected repeats and then what it really does (with black lines). the same score works as expected in 2.1.
tried deleting the "2." open lines, after that it does as i want it to. however, i would like to keep the "2." volta lines in the score..
any suggestions? changing some parameters or whatever.. thankyou in advance
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| what i want it to do.png | 34.38 KB |
| what it does.png | 37.34 KB |
| skuska volty.mscz | 7.82 KB |
Comments
There was a similar request some days before: https://musescore.org/en/node/282497. The playback of both scores works as expected with MuseScore 2.1, but not with 2.3.2 and 3.x.
So if I don't miss something (about settings with MS 3.x), seems to be a bug and regression.
In reply to There was a similar request… by kuwitt
thank you. so deleting open "2." lines is the only solution for now, i'll try to live with that :) or do an mp3 with no 2 volta lines and just print the score with them
EDIT no it's not :D thanks for all the help
In reply to There was a similar request… by kuwitt
also, mr. Johan Temmerman answered me in the facebook support group:
"MuseScore has a bit of troubles in figuring out to which "repeatsection" the volta applies. It thinks it's part of the repeatcounting started by the start repeat barline of m5, while it actually still applies to the previous repeat-start bar.
I'll have to ponder a bit on how to improve the algorithm to possibly auto-detect this; but doing so might lose some of the flexibility the overall improved interpretation since MS2.2 has."
so i assume yeah it's kind of a minor "bug", that prevents worse things to happen :)
Workaround: Set the 1st Volta 2's repeat list to "1,2"
See also https://musescore.org/en/node/282497, same issue, same day, different score and user