Saving Score in Concert view causes transposed Parts to reopen in Concert, causing mismatched key signatures.

• Apr 1, 2019 - 08:31
Reported version
3.0
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project
  1. Create new file with one or more transposing instruments Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.00.50.png
  2. Create parts Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.01.10.png Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.01.24.png Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.01.40.png
  3. Save file with "Concert Pitch" selected in score view. Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.03.58.png Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.04.12.png
  4. Close and reopen saved file
    Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.04.26.png Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.04.37.png
  5. The Part and Score both have "Concert Pitch" pressed down but the key signature is not transposed in the Part view Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.04.44.png Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.04.53.png
  6. Transposing is now incorrect. If I deselect the "Concert Pitch" button in the Part view, it re-transposes the key signature.
    Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.05.02.png
  7. The Score's key signature transposition no longer matches the Part
    Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.05.11.png Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.05.26.png Screenshot 2019-04-01 00.05.32.png
  8. When exporting parts, the parts are now either Concert (untransposed) notes with a transposed key signature, or correctly transposed notes with the wrong key signature. demo-Bb_Clarinet.pdf demo-Score_and_Parts.pdf

This can be fixed by placing a new key signature in the score, but the issue pops up again when I save and reopen the file. The only workaround is saving the file with the Score in Transposed (not Concert) view.

Attachment Size
demo.mscz 5.48 KB

Comments