Import from MusicXML error
Hi
I'm doing arranging in Cakewalk and exporting to MusicXML, but when I open my XML in MuseScore, my "long" notes becomes 2 notes in MuseScore. Is there a solution to this ?
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| musescore.jpg | 46.39 KB |
| cakewalk.jpg | 68 KB |
Comments
See #331007: [MusicXML import] support tie element, known issue with Cakewalk, its MusicXML export is not complete
In reply to See #331007: [MusicXML… by Jojo-Schmitz
No, I forgot to write that. I downloaded a program called Finale Notpad in order to check this. It imports my file correctly.
In reply to No, I forgot to write that… by steenelm1
Then Finale Notepad is more forgiving for such errors.
Making MuseScore more forgiving too is what that issue above is about
In reply to Then Finale Notepad is more… by Jojo-Schmitz
My first guess was also that Cakewalk had the error. At least I found out that I can import it in Finalenotepad and then export it again, which works.
In reply to My first guess was also that… by steenelm1
Thanks, I've added that as a workaround to that issue
See also https://musescore.org/en/node/330913, where this first came up. That has an extensive analysis of the problem.
Caklewalk's MusicXML export does not encode ties correctly. MuseScore imports correctly and (maybe too) strict
In reply to See also https://musescore… by Jojo-Schmitz
Ok thanks for the info.