I tried sending a music xml file to a friend, and he keeps getting an older version of the song with mistakes in it that I have already corrected.
Reported version
3.6
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S5 - Suggestion
Reproducibility
Always
Status
needs info
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
Oh,_Our_Savior_(Our_Heav'nly_Friend).mxl | 8.12 KB |
Comments
That file was encoded 2022-08-26. I'm betting your friend has an older file. Either decompress and read their file with a suitable editor and check the date and compare it with the file you posted here or get your friend to copy their file to a different name, send it to you and post it here so that folks can compare the two.
Even the attachment you received from me has the same mistakes in it that I have already corrected.
Then you attached the wrong file
The xml file inside the mxl has a timestamp of 2022-08-26 17:05
In reply to Then you attached the wrong… by Jojo-Schmitz
I even tried recreating the file, and it just did the same thing. I only have one file to attach. I'll send the PDF of what it should look like.
In reply to I even tried recreating the… by msea35
At first it pops up looking just fine, but then it changes to what appears to be a previous stage of development, something I have not intentionally saved and didn't realize was saved somewhere in the system.
Maybe caused by export/Import?
As far as layout is concerned only the mscz should keep everything
What is the difference between the PDF and the MXL you're concerned about?
Is it this?
If so: IIRC that's a known MusicXML Import/Export issue
Edit: seems I remembered wrongly, I was thinking of #329060: [MusicXML export] decimals in metronome markings get separated, but this here seems different.
If that is the issue you're talking about...
The XML looks like this:
Changing that to
seems to fix the issue. Looks like a MuseScore MusicXML export issue
and also this:
Seems invisible tempo texts become visible on import
Actually the visibility is not even exported, here's the XML:
So this seems to be a MuseScore MusicXML export issue
as per https://www.w3.org/2021/06/musicxml40/musicxml-reference/elements/metro… it should work to change that to
but unfortunatly it does not, MuseScore('s MusicXML parser) complains about that
print-object
Are these the problems you are seeing?