Caesura Playback Issue (in Muse4)
Reported version
4.x-dev
Type
Functional
Frequency
Many
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
GitHub issue
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project
- Create score with piano (I am using musesounds playback)
- Add caesura to music
- Play music
The sounds will continue to play while the music should be stopped, then once the music gets going again they stack on top of each other.
Comments
I confirm this issue with note - in the attached the FIRST caesura is honored pausing for 2secs, the SECOND caesura is ignored
Two is few
addendum: if I save and reload, the caesuras play correctly. The next one I add is ignored, but if I save and reload it plays correctly. At this point I have nine caesuras and nine reloads which is "many"
I am guessing this is an artifact of the new interpretation software... I am using Muse Sounds... in Muse3 caesuras are always honored
addendum: in this newly added caesura, it is ignored where marked, but played two bars late - second time I noticed this
again - it resolves if save and reload
Please stop that changing of frequency. 2 reporters makes few.
are you saying "few" does not refer to the number of times the bug occurs? would you please update that field then?
It got reported by the OP and you, that makes two.
Two to five is Few.
If you don't know what a setting means, don't tamper with it 😉
For the record, "frequency" is how often a bug is reported; "reproducibility" is how often it occurs for those people who have reported it. This information is present in the FAQ article that appears when you click "read the instructions" upon posting a new issue. I suppose it would be good if that link was also presented when commenting on an issue. But I also think this issue tracker is likely to be retired in the not-too-distant future.
In any case, a number of reports of caesura playback issues already exist on GitHub, so I'm closing this one as du0licate (search "caesura" on GitHub issues to find them, there are several).
Same issue here. Using Musescore V4 and Musesounds. It stucks somehow, but does not pause at all. Issue still not resolved, right?
See https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/15305
As per @Marc Sabatella:
The pause is honored after the playback info is regenerated - save/reload, for example, but also any edit that changes the playback.
see https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/20505
MuseScore 4.1 was fine, but with 4.2, placing a note immediately before a caesura or section break causes that note to sustain (instead of pausing)
That's a separate issue and also being dealt with
Other than that this issue here has been discontinued, so use the one on GitHub
This is already reported on GitHub, so no need to open a new issue. But also, definitely no need - ever - to respond to issues here in this obsolete tracker. The original bug discussed here, btw, is unrelated to the new one, but the original one has a pending fix.