Export to musicxml cut short
Reported version
3.5
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
needs info
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
- Load exercise.mscx
- Export to musicxml
Only the first 12 measures get exported
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Exercise.mscx | 111.56 KB |
Comments
When I exported it to musicxml it was complete. Can you attach your musicxml file?
Sorry, one more question, what makes you think only 12 measures were exported? Did you import it to another program or examine the musicxml?
Musicxml file added
In reply to Musicxml file added by emilianoheyns
I re-imported the musicxml file into MuseScore. You mean maybe it's an import error, not an output error?
The musicxml you attached is complete. When I open it in MuseScore I get all of the measures even though they are slightly differently formatted.
I see. When I import that musicxml file I consistently only see 12 measures. But when I save it as midi and import that, all measures are indeed present again. But if I export the musicxml file to mscz and import that, still only 12 measures.
I'm on macos big sur if that matters.
(I agree it is to be expected that the formatting changes)
Ok, attach the defective imported file. It's not out of the question that import or export works slightly differently in mac (you) vs windows (me) due to reading and writing routines. Perhaps the mac is stopping for some reason. On my windows system, measure 12 is on page 2 with a page break and measure 13 starts on page 3 etc.
This for me shows only 12 measures.
For some reason, you get 12 more measures than I do when you import it. I show a corruption and can open it, even with my xml viewer so this needs to be looked at by someone who can look at it in a debug build.
As a test, open the attached musicxml I created to see if it works for you.
Sorry, attached the wrong file
That one opens just like the one I made. I guess a Mac user will need to look into the problem. Which OS do you use in case that makes a difference?
I'm on big sur
OK, BigSur, that's a hint. Very new and as of yet entirely untested. Intel or ARM?
Intel
In reply to Intel by emilianoheyns
I renumber the measures at two point by entering a negative number after "Add to measure number", and measures after the first renumbering don't show up. If I insert measures before the renumbered measure, those show up when I re-import the musicxml.
In reply to I renumber the measures at… by emilianoheyns
Correction: if I add a measure to the mscz, export to musicxml, and re-import, everything shows up.