Header and Footer Text is not identical to 3.5 scores when opened in 3.6
Reported version
3.6
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project
When loading a score from 3.5 into 3.6, and choosing to keep the old style, header and footer text is not converted to previous. For example, header text becomes bold, and footer text is larger than 3.5.
Comments
Same problem; my header and footer settings never save, along with a few other things (hairpins don't stay at the default +-3.50 Y?).
Regarding the original problem with header and footer in scores imported from earlier version - please attach a score you are having trouble with. In my tests this works as expected, with one exception. If you happen to customize a style setting to be different from the 3.5 default but the same as the 3.6 default, then when importing into 3.6, MuseScore is confused and reverts to the 3.5 default. See #315006: Headers in imported 3.5.2 files are lost (perhaps due to style properties being reset to default in the RC). But other than that one case, everything else should work fine. So if you are experiencing a problem other than this, we would need a sample score.
As for any unrelated problem with settings not saving, or anything at all to do with hairpins, we would also need sample scores and precise steps to reproduce those problems. but please do so in a separate forum thread.
In reply to Regarding the original… by Marc Sabatella
What are the defaults for 3.5.2 and 3.6? I'm trying to test the defaults but I can't tell if I'm setting stuff to be different from those.
Default for what, specifically? Header and footer fonts? FreeSerif, 8 pt. Presumably you have 3.6 and can see the new defaults for yourself, but for the record, both are Edwin; header is 11 pt bold, footer is 9 pt normal. But if you don't have both installed, there is no way for you to test this - the problem only occurs when saving scores in 3.5 and then opening them in 3.6. If you have a score that you believe exhibits a problem, just attach it and we can test further from there.
In reply to Default for what,… by Marc Sabatella
Yea, I meant the header/footer styling. I'm working on a 3.6 copy of a score I created last fall that I have kept up the updates with ever since. I want to keep the header at 10 pt. and footer at 8 pt. but upon saving, it regresses when I open it again. Same goes with hairpins (they regress to Y: 2 sp. rather than the original Y: 3.5 sp. which I think is the default, at least for pre-3.6.) and page numbers (I like them on the bottom center, but it keeps adding the top right one after every save). I'm not saving anything in 3.5; everything is running on the 3.6. If this sounds like something else I'll try to create a sample score.
So indeed, if this is all in 3.6, it's unrelated to the issue here, which is about scores created in 3.5 and imported into 3.6. Please start a new thread and attach the actual score with a problem, plus precise steps to reproduce the problem. It doesn't happen for most scores, something must be unique about yours in particular, which is why we need you to attach it.
In reply to So indeed, if this is all in… by Marc Sabatella
Made an issue post including this: https://musescore.org/en/node/315847
Better #315847: Certain Formatting Changes/Resets Do Not Save in Parts
In reply to Regarding the original… by Marc Sabatella
Hi, I've attached a score I've had trouble with. I'm pretty sure that non-bold headers are the 3.5 default and bold headers are the 3.6 default, and musescore is not restoring to the 3.6 style settings.
These are the font face and size settings
In reply to These are the font face and… by Jojo-Schmitz
The issue is that I didn't set it to bold in 3.5, and I don't want it to be changed to bold by default.
I don't know why it isn't set to that in the score, it says so in the file settings that it's bold when I opened it first in 3.6
It isn't set to bold when I open that score in 3.6
Except in parts, but that is dealt with in #315847: Certain Formatting Changes/Resets Do Not Save in Parts
In reply to Except in parts, but that is… by Jojo-Schmitz
You're right, apologies - my issue(s) is/are dealt with in that post.
Sorry, I've never had issues with Musescore before and I've never done bug reporting before, so apologies if I'm making mistakes.
No problem these thing do happen