Problem with XML Export
I try to practice piano with the Piano Marvel program.
The program needs XML files.
What I have done
- I created a file in Musicsore
- I put the fingerings over the notes
- I export the file as * .musicxml and * .mxl
Problem in "Pianomarvel"
- The fingerings are not directly above the notes.
- The fingerings are above the staff line.
(The stems cover the fingerings) - The fingerings for the proposal notes are missing.
Experiment
- I exported the mxl and musicxml after"Final Notepad"
- In Finale Notepad I saved this again as an xml file.
Result in "PianoMarvel":
- The fingerings are correctly above the note OK.
- The fingerings of the proposal notes are missing.
Here is the PDF with the errors and pictures
https://docdro.id/zmRUgQ9
The XLM-files are attached
I would be grateful for any help.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| File River_Flows_In_You-HA to xml-from Finale2018 to XML.xml.mxl | 14.39 KB |
| River_Flows_In_You-HA to xml.xml | 300.02 KB |
| River_Flows_In_You-HA to xml-from MusicScore to mxl.mxl | 12.04 KB |
Comments
Can you try this using version 3? Version 2 will no longer be updated. I'm working with the programmers to get version 3 to follow the xml standard. It may take a little time, but if you work with me we can do it. You can get version 3 at https://musescore.org/en/download.
In reply to Can you try this using… by mike320
Hi,
I am very glad that you want to help me.
All my attempts have been made with this version.
OS: Windows 10 (10.0), Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.0.0.4785, revision: c1a5e4c
Thank you so much
In reply to Hi, I am very glad that you… by vatifasu
Update to 3.0.1
But fingerings are still being worked at, not sure whether that affects MusicXML too though
In reply to Hi, I am very glad that you… by vatifasu
Here are missing –
- the 2nd and 3rd stanzas
- the Guitarchords
The fingerings are no longer under the notes.
The fingerings are only on one line
Please look at the picture in the Appendix
Danke
In reply to Here are missing – - the 2nd… by vatifasu
Upgrade to 3.0.1, at least the PDF landscape truncating is fixed there
Reg. fingering see #280807: Regression - 3.0 doesn’t distinguish between fingerings and LH guitar fingerings.
In reply to Here are missing – - the 2nd… by vatifasu
I do see a lot of problems with finger positions being retained, particularly whe there are multiple fingerings on a chord. Can you upgrade to 3.0.1 and redo the .mscz and .musicxml files and explain what the issue is in https://musescore.org/en/node/add/project_issue?pid=1236? This will bring it to the attention of programmers looking at fixing this. Someone is actually working on guitar fingerings and this may be able to be incorporated into his fix.
In reply to I do see a lot of problems… by mike320
HI,
I have the latest version.
OS: Windows 10 (10.0), Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.0.1.5087, revision: 06a66a2
Picture 1
mscz created in Musicscore eported to musicxlm
picture 2
musicxlm import in PianoMarvel
There are still problems with the export * .mscz-to xml or musicxml.
The fingerings are written together at the chord.
(I sent an e-mail to the developer, thanks for the tip)
In reply to Here are missing – - the 2nd… by vatifasu
Thanks for #282119: Problem with XML Export
I had a problem with my left side being cut off on importing to Piano Marvel. Try going into Page Settings (right click on your music). I made my margins bigger so nothing would get cut off on the export. I had to make this one at 22.00 mm all around, and it worked. So when I export the MIDI and XML with MuseScore, and then do the import to Piano Marvel, nothing is cut off anymore. I hope this helps. I have not had any problem with the fingerings. I am on Musescore Version 3.0.1.5087
In reply to I had a problem with my left… by Judy G
Hello Judy G,
can you please post a picture of your fingerings?
Are the Fignersets with you among the notes?
Many Thanks